Solve this one

and your point would certainly be well taken if there was anybody around here who has posted a riddle and added stipulations afterwards. Now, since i haven't dont that you still haven't made your point.

and asnwering a question is, which he is known for doing, is something completely diffirent from joining you on a hike, wouldn't you agree?

I could state, and rightly argue for it that your suggestion is a request and not really a question. The question "can you walk with me the way to life" could be answered "Yes I can" or "No I can't" without really meaning he has to walk with you. So what you're wanting is for him to come with you, which is a request.

I have read the solution on the previous page and that hole still applies, that solution would work if you knew for certain which number person you were and who he lies to, it says every second person to both his lies and his truths even if you were to assume that it implied every other person you still don't know whether the lies or truths correlate with the evens or the odds. In response to adams' response how do you know that he isn't going to lie about what he would tell the next person the more in depth you ask the question the more tangled the web becomes.

yes he will tell the next person the opposite what he will tell you but you do not know what he will tell the next person. Even if you ask him what he will tell the next person there is no certainty he will tell you the truth.
Its his turn to lie you ask him what he will tell the next person who asks where to go he shows you say path a but he is lying so he would actually tell the next person b which means you chould take b
Its his turn for truth you ask him what he will tell the next person who asks him where to go he says path b which means you would take path a because he would be lying to the next person

see you don't know.

i got cut off my batt on my lap top died i understand that solution I do but the point I was about to make is you can't even be certain that he is aware of this lying phenomena if he knows that he lies to every other person then yes that solution holds but if he doesn't then.. well I think you can see where i am going that was what I was beginning to get at before.