there are a stealing refreshment?

   Share on Facebook  
sky_meat  #168462  Sat, 10 Dec 05 05:27 PM

While i was reading a poem by Jone Galsworthy ( winner of 1932 Nobel prize in literature), i came across one sentence : "They are a stealing and silent refreshment that we perhaps do not think about, but which goes on all the time. "

I am just wondering why in that sentence the writter use " a stealing and silent refreshment" after " they are" ? I understand if the sentence was " there is a stealing and silent refreshment.."  but now i am confused. Someone please tell me what grammar is uesed here? thanks in advance!

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Sun, Apr 10 2005
New Member (10)
CalifJim  #168477  Sat, 10 Dec 05 05:45 PM
"they" refers back to something plural.  In poetic style it may even refer forward to something plural, or even to something outside of the poem.  Without context you leave us all guessing as much as you.  Can you find anything plural which precedes this passage in the poem?

CJ

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (15,971)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
pieanne  #168478  Sat, 10 Dec 05 05:49 PM

Here it is:

A choirboy's voice, a ship in sail, an opening flower, a town at night, the song of the blackbird, a lovely poem, leaf shadows, a child's grace, the starry skies, a cathedral, apple trees in spring, a throughbred horse, sheep-bells on a hill, a rippling stream, a butterfly, the crescent moon--the thousand sights or sounds or words that keep the human spirit from death by drought. They are a stealing and silent refreshment

 

Smile [:)]

 

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jan 20 2005
South of France ...But I'm Belgian!
Veteran Member (7,512)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
I'm glad to help, but I'm not a native! And please excuse my typos...
CalifJim  #168480  Sat, 10 Dec 05 05:55 PM
pieanne to the rescue!

Now if that's not plural, I don't know what is!

CJ

  
pieanne  #168481  Sat, 10 Dec 05 06:00 PM

LOL! Neither do I!  Smile [:)]  (Hyperplural?)

(maybe there are even too many of them for a stealing refreshment)

  
sky_meat  #168628  Sun, 11 Dec 05 03:42 AM

Thanks pieanne for providing the peom.

But it seems i did not make myself clear. My question is not about thoes things, it is obvious that that is plural. My question is about why the author used " a " after " are" ?  From my limited english knowledge, the sentence structure like " there are ..." should be followed by a plural, right? For example: " there is a good reason." but we can't say " ther are a good reasons"  But here how come the author associated " there are..." with " a stealing refreshment"?

help me please~

  
CalifJim  #168641  Sun, 11 Dec 05 05:59 AM
"they" is a completely different word from "there".
"they", which means "those things (or people) mentioned before", is used in the poem, not "there".
When the subject is "they", the verb is plural -- "are" in this case.
So "They are a ..." in the poem is correct.
(Your subject line is incorrect.)

Hope that helps.  Smile [:)]
CJ

  
sky_meat  #168896  Mon, 12 Dec 05 02:00 AM
i got it i think, thx CJ Smile [:)]
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions