Teacher David????

   Share on Facebook  
MrPedantic  #283697  Sat, 21 Oct 06 12:07 AM

Imagine a group of EFL trainee teachers.

They are travelling to X-ia, to teach English to the Xs. But first, they have to learn a little X-ish themselves.

They are to be taught X-ish by Teacher A and Teacher B.

Teacher A has a poster on his wall. It says:

"If you're English, and you want to understand X-ish thoroughly, you must put aside your English ways of thinking, and learn to think like an X."

Teacher B also has a poster. It says:

"Don't let X-ish culture dominate your usage."

_______

Now here's my question, Milky: 

Which approach is more likely to foster awareness of, and sensitivity to, the X-ish culture?

Teacher A's? or Teacher B's?

MrP

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Oct 12 2004
Veteran Member (12,168)
Proficient SpeakerSystemAdministrator
...opella forensis / adducit febris...
milky  #283701  Sat, 21 Oct 06 12:22 AM

Read my lips:

You are too much, Mr P. My discussions with you end here.

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jan 15 2004
Senior Member (3,149)
Hume said that if we had perfect or complete descriptive knowledge of reality, we could not, by reasoning, derive a single valid "ought".
nona the brit  #283716  Sat, 21 Oct 06 01:04 AM

Read my lips

Milky, are you aware that is a very rude (as in ill-mannered) thing to say to someone?

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Sep 22 2004
England
Veteran Member (11,450)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
The name says it all.
milky  #283726  Sat, 21 Oct 06 01:23 AM
 Nona The Brit wrote:

Read my lips

Milky, are you aware that is a very rude (as in ill-mannered) thing to say to someone?

Please see MR P's post about Jean-Marie le Pen. If you think that post is not provocative and rude, we have a problem with moderation here.

  
milky  #283727  Sat, 21 Oct 06 01:24 AM
 Nona The Brit wrote:

Read my lips

Milky, are you aware that is a very rude (as in ill-mannered) thing to say to someone?

Why not delete it if offends you? You have the reins.

  
milky  #283739  Sat, 21 Oct 06 02:05 AM
"Honorifics are essential in the Korean language, and I sometimes sense in fluent English-speaking Korean colleagues and students a frustration that English is so blunt, so lacking in means of showing courtesy (and of withholding it). (See Rhee, 1994)."
  
milky  #283740  Sat, 21 Oct 06 02:10 AM

Compare this quote with Mr P's below it:

  • Different languages – and different Englishes – might not share Americans’ conversation conventions. The topics and styles for small talk in the U.S. might give offense in France or Japan. To Arabs, U. S. conversation can seem tepid and unenthusiastic. To Americans, German Swiss sometimes seem brusquely inconsiderate of “face.” To Dutch listeners, Americans can seem too prone to self-promotion, while to Germans, Americans often sound absurdly optimistic.
  • [link] 

    --

    Mr P wrote:

    If you're English, and you want to understand Russian or Japanese or German thoroughly, you have to put aside your English ways of thinking, and learn to think in Russian or Japanese or German.

      
    MrPedantic  #283818  Sat, 21 Oct 06 09:24 AM

    I'm sorry if it offended you, Milky. But if you're entitled to say that "you must put aside your English ways of thinking" reflects British cultural imperialism, I'm surely entitled to point out that "don't let others impose their culture" is the watchword of several unpleasant political organisations.

    However, I won't mention it again.

    MrP

      
    milky  #283834  Sat, 21 Oct 06 10:51 AM

    Plonk.

    :

      
    AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL Linguistics Discussion Forum
    © 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
    Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service