tenses

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
badegine  #511394  Thu, 08 May 08 10:31 PM

Fine - apart from the comma in b, which should be:

'I'm so glad! What a relief. The design of the control system has been troubling me, and sometimes when I look at the equations I wonder why the second variable is a function of y2.'

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Thu, May 8 2008
New Member (21)
Kooyeen  #511395  Thu, 08 May 08 10:37 PM
I would say it's ok if you've been designing it up to now... and it's been troubling you.
But if you gave up designing it at a certain point in the past, I'd use the past... it had been troubling you.
Again, just my opinion. I don't understand the present perfect continuous either, I just pretend I do! Stick out tongue
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Dec 22 2005
Italy
Senior Member (3,706)
Moderator
*Parental Advisory*Explicit Posts
New2grammar  #511398  Thu, 08 May 08 10:46 PM

badegine,

What do you think of the following?

'I'm so glad! What a relief. The design of the control system had been troubling me, and sometimes when I looked at the equations I wondered why the second variable was function of y2.'

What do you feel when you hear it in the context mentioned before? Try to avoid using grammatical terms in your explaination. I would like to know how you feel as a native speaker (I think you're, right?).

Also, which tense would you prefer? I'm trying to see whether it's a matter of preference.

Thanks in advance!

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Nov 21 2006
Veteran Member (6,842)
Who wants to go sailing around the world with me?
Anonymous  #511428  Thu, 08 May 08 11:55 PM

Hi,

I would like to hear what badegine would say.

I think your sentence is good and conveys the sense of your troubling days over the design of the control system is OVER.

Your sentence:

'I'm so glad! What a relief. The design of the control system had been troubling me, and sometimes when I looked at the equations I wondered why the second variable was function of y2.'

I think this is not good since the tenses are not consistent. Am I correct? Whenever I use a past perfect continuous, I look for a clue word/phrase (clause too?)  that indicates something has been occurring some time before something else like "He had been watching TV until his father came home at 8 p.m. yesterday evening." -- Here "until his father came home at 8 p.m. yesterday evening" is a clue word or phrase. 

And according to that, this wouldn't be correct. Am I right?

'I'm so glad! What a relief. The design of the control system had been troubling me, and sometimes when I look at the equations I wonder why the second variable was function of y2.'

  
New2grammar  #511533  Fri, 09 May 08 08:20 AM

Hi Anon, I don't understand the need for a 'clue phrase' phrase explanation you provided. You mean you don't use the past perfect continous tense without an additional phrase like what you suggested in your  example but you have no problem with the present perfect continous standing alone? Interesting- something new to me.

 

  
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions