"than" as a conjunction

   Share on Facebook  
Anonymous  #574636  Thu, 09 Oct 08 02:29 AM
Hi,
Please take a look at these sentences and my related comments, and tell me what you think.

1. She has more money than her husband/her husband does/her husband has. -- I think all three can be used but wonder why this one can have 'her husband does' as a viable option, whereas the other two don't seem to have that option.

2, She runs faster than her husband/her husband does. -- I think both of them can be used, whereas the use of phrase "her husband has" can not.

3. She plays tennis better than he husband/her husband does. -- Similar in my assessment to no. 2.
   
  
This is a live chat room, hosted on the chat page. You can also click here to see the chat in fullscreen.
Clive  #574654  Thu, 09 Oct 08 04:27 AM
Hi,
Please take a look at these sentences and my related comments, and tell me what you think.

1. She has more money than her husband/her husband does/her husband has. --
I think all three can be used Yes
but wonder why this one can have 'her husband does' as a viable option, whereas the other two don't seem to have that option. They do, ie you can say 'than her husband does' in #2 and #3. I think you meant to refer here to 'her husband does  has'. 'Has' is OK here, because it is the main verb, as in 'She has more money'.

2, She runs faster than her husband/her husband does. -- I think both of them can be used, whereas the use of phrase "her husband has" can not.Correct, because the main verb here is 'runs', not 'has'. You could say
'She runs faster than her husband runs', although it's repetitive.

3. She plays tennis better than he husband/her husband does. -- Similar in my assessment to no. 2. And my comment is similar.

Clive
  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member (22,480)
ModeratorTeachers
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
Anonymous  #574691  Thu, 09 Oct 08 06:44 AM
Hi, Thank you.

I have some questions on this though:

1. She has more money than her husband/her husband does/her husband has. --
I think all three can be used Yes
but wonder why this one can have 'her husband does' as a viable option, whereas the other two don't seem to have that option. They do, ie you can say 'than her husband does' in #2 and #3. I think you meant to refer here to 'her husband does  has'. 'Has' is OK here, because it is the main verb, as in 'She has more money'.

I think we can have the pattern "She has more money than her husband does" because what is implied possibly is "She does have more money than her husband does," and I think it is OK to assume a possbility of the auxiliary verb "does"? being there.

Likewise, could we think in a similar or the same line for these? As long as we can fit the auxiliary verb (is this auxiliary anyway?), then, the structure "... more than he/she does" is possible?

I think these are stative verbs:

consider  She (does consider) considers it more suitable than her husband/her husband does  
like:      She (does like) likes this food more than her husband/her husband does.
feel:   She (does feel) feels her cousin is nicer than than her husband/hur husband does.

So, my overall argument is that if you can fit the auxiliary verb "does" in the main (first) verb part, then you can use "does" in an appropriate place after the conjunction "than"; and only exception is when you have a "be" verb in the main part of the sentence like this:

Not good:  She is feeling better than her husband does.  
  
Clive  #574819  Thu, 09 Oct 08 02:47 PM
Hi,

Yes, you can use the appropriate auxiliary.

eg She (does like) likes this food more than her husband/her husband does.

eg She is feeling better than her husband does is..  

Or you can, if you want to be verbose or emphatic, repeat the main verb.

eg She likes this food more than her husband likes it.

eg She is feeling better than her husband is feeling.

Best wishes, Clive  

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL Basic English Grammar Questions and Help
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service