The accusitive case

   Share on Facebook  
Guest  #13090  Sat, 15 Nov 03 05:16 AM
The accusitve case. Could you write me three or four short sentences using the accusitive case?

Appreciated

H.M. Hall
  
whl626  #13110  Sat, 15 Nov 03 01:26 PM
The house which my uncle built cost him US100,000. ( which is the relative pronoun in accusative case )

She is the girl whom I met on the street the other day. ( whom is the relative pronoun in accusative case )

I say what I mean. ( what is the relative pronoun in accusative case )


  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Sun, Aug 24 2003
Regular Member (882)
Learn English every day
Pemmican  #13143  Sun, 16 Nov 03 03:10 PM
whl, how can you see if it's dative or accusative??

I learned at school, that there's just an object-case in English that doesn't differenciate between dative and accusative.
I'd like to know if and how you can distinguish those two cases, thx a lot
  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Aug 21 2003
Westphalia, Germany
Regular Member (569)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
Wâ mag ich mich nu vinden? wâ mac ich mich nu suochen, wâ? nu bin ich hie und bin ouch dâ und enbin doch weder dâ noch hie. wer wart ouch sus verirret ie?wer wart ie sus...
whl626  #13210  Mon, 17 Nov 03 03:59 AM
In the first example : which = the house , and my uncle built ( the house )( which ), and since it is an object of the verb built. That means this relative pronoun is in the accusative case.

The same goes with the second example.

Regarding the third. what = something that, I say something that I mean ( I mean something )

and since something is the object of the verb ' mean ' so, what is the relative pronoun in the accusative case.Smile [:)]

  
Pemmican  #13283  Mon, 17 Nov 03 04:18 PM
So how can you see then whether a verb needs a dative or an accusative pronoun?
I mean there's no change in the form of the pronoun or any other noun in a sentence so how can you see what case is used?

So would something be a pronoun in the accusative case if I said: "I built something"?
Also there's no change in personal pronouns in these cases, e.g. if you said:
"I will help her" and "I can see her"
In German you can see the difference in these sentences:
"Ich werde ihr helfen" and "Ich kann sie sehen":
'ihr' in the first sentence is the personal pronoun in its dative case (because the verb helfen reigns the dative) while 'sie' in the 2nd sentence is the pronoun in its accusative case (because the verb sehen reigns the accusative).

Is there any way in English that you can see whether it's dative or accusative?
Thanks for your reply.

  
whl626  #13316  Tue, 18 Nov 03 01:24 AM
" I sent her a postcard. " ( ' her ' is the pronoun in dative case ) because " I sent her " is not a complete sentence that you need an object ' a postcard ' to form a complete sentence.

dative = the form of a noun, a pronoun or an adjective when it is the indirect object of a verb or is connected with the indirect object.

" I will help her " ( ' her ' is the pronoun in the accusative case )

" She will help me " ( ' she ' is the pronoun in the nominative case ) because the pronounce is placed as the subject of the verb whereas ' her ' is in the object of the verb.

  
Mike A.  #13362  Tue, 18 Nov 03 07:16 PM
The first thing to note is the spelling: the correct spelling is a-c-c-u-s-a-t-i-v-e. Another thing to note is that the term often employed to identify the "case" of words like "him", "her" and "whom" is Objective, rather than Accusative (which is misleading in a simplified grammar like English's.)

Unlike German, English doesn't really have a well-developed Dative or Accusative case. We used to have those cases at an earlier stage of the language's development, but now those cases are only vestigial. Our "allgemein" Objective case, where it exists at all, performs both Dative and Accusative functions. What gives you the difference in meaning is generally word order.

For example, in the sentence "I gave him a spoon" -- which in German would be something like "Ich gab ihm einen Loeffel" -- "him" is a word in the Objective case, but it is clearly performing a dative function here. If you want to, you can decide that "him" is in the Dative case, but in English grammar it doesn't make much sense to think of a Dative case. We know that "him" is the indirect object of the verb -- i.e., performs a dative function -- because it *precedes* what is obviously the direct object, "spoon". Note that "spoon", the direct object, is unmarked by case ending, unlike the German.

On the other hand, in a sentence like "I saw him yesterday" -- which in German would be "Ich sah ihn gestern" -- it's the same word "him", in the same Objective case, but since there is no possible role for "him" in this sentence other than the direct object, you know that it has to be the direct object.

In American English, the normal practice would be for indirect objects to precede the direct objects: "I gave him a spoon." In British English -- or so I believe -- sometimes the practice is the opposite: the British might say "I gave it him" -- where "it" (the direct object) comes first.

Hope this helps.

Mike
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Sat, Nov 15 2003
New Member (09)
Anonymous  #149895  Thu, 20 Oct 05 05:11 PM

Quoted: In British English -- or so I believe -- sometimes the practice is the opposite: the British might say "I gave it him" -- where "it" (the direct object) comes first.

It would be "I gave it to him" in Standard British English.

In some regional British accents, say Yorkshire; then the "to" might be dropped, as it is implied.

Your other sentance "I gave him a spoon." would also pass as Standard British.

(Though more commonly you'd hear: "I gave a spoon to him" or "I have given him a spoon")  

 



 

  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service