We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Share this topic:
Tearsofjoy  +  192647 Sat, 04 Feb 06 08:37 PM

I have to agree with Rishonly, Adomi. I am definitely very surprised to hear that you have trouble with the British accent!

I have to disagree as to your natural accent being the best, though. A very thick regional accent is very difficult for most people to follow, and in many cases the words are not pronounced as they ought to be. It is, therefore, wise to cultivate an accent that everyone can understand.

The Australian accent, for one, is one that I find totally incomprehensible.

Joined on Mon, Sep 19 2005
India
Contributing Member 1,324
God help you if you are a phoenix And you dare to rise up from the ash A thousand eyes will smolder with jealousy While you are just flying past - Ani DiFranco (32 Flavours)
This is a live chat room, hosted on the chat page. You can also click here to see the chat in fullscreen.
adomi  +  192779 Sun, 05 Feb 06 10:09 AM
 Rishonly wrote:

Wow! It is surprising, though, that an Asian is well acquainted with American accent but not with British accent. Quite interesting, Adomi.

Indeed Rish, for an Asian it certainly shouldn't be a problem to get along with the English accent, but guess what?  I'm not AsianBig Smile [:D]. I'm AFRICANWink [;)], maybe that's the point. Most of the English speakers around me, I mean among westerners, are Americans, and Aussies. I recently met with a British and I mean it when I say I have trouble following him. As to the Australians, well, it may be surprising Joy, but I have no problem following them.

Joy, I agree with your mentionning that "the thick regional accent is difficult to follow". Had that difference(in countries, regions, races and so on) not being, I don't think the accent would  have ever been an issue in any languageCake [^].  I think you are Indian, aren't youSmile [:)]? I guess people around you understand you when you speak Hindi or Tammil, or.... anyway your mother tongue. Did you try and cultivate  that accent? I know one might need to cultivate his accent even when speaking his mother tongue, but what I'd like to stress is, why don't we keep the accent we have by birth and try and pronounce the words as the ought to be pronounced in the language we are trying to learn? That's why I mentionned that, the emphasis should be put on the language first, and when we are in a foreign place or with people with different accents, try and get use to their accent, while keeping ours as simple(Natural) as possible. Do we necessarily have to speak with a different  accent when we speak another language? Allow me to get back a while on the British accent. The British friend I'm telling you about, has no problem following me, yet I'm using my normal(Natural) Cameroonian accent. I'm sure by 2 to 3 weeks I'll be able to follow him too. Usually what happens is, people that live for long time in a foreign country tend to acquire the national/local accent, which is understandable, because of the influence of their environment. 

Joined on Thu, Nov 4 2004
Bangladesh/Cameroonian
Regular Member 609
"Practice makes perfect"
rishonly  +  192883 Sun, 05 Feb 06 06:11 PM
 Adomi wrote:
 Rishonly wrote:

Wow! It is surprising, though, that an Asian is well acquainted with American accent but not with British accent. Quite interesting, Adomi.

Indeed Rish, for an Asian it certainly shouldn't be a problem to get along with the English accent, but guess what?  I'm not AsianBig Smile [:D]. I'm AFRICANWink [;)], maybe that's the point.  

That resolves the puzzle, Adomi. I see!. I simply thought you are from Bangladesh.

Joined on Sat, Mar 5 2005
KUMBAKONAM,INDIA
Contributing Member 1,782
Regards, Krishna
KYsheeplover06  +  194013 Wed, 08 Feb 06 05:02 AM

I believe accent isn't something you learn, it's just what you grow up with. For instance, when I was a child I was taught to speak in an American "southern" accent, which I've come to find quite charming (although others would beg to differ...) but the point is I've learned to imitate several of the different British accents for a short while, but I could never keep them up in my everyday speech. Your accent is just what comes natural to you...

 

Perhaps I'm out on a limb on this subject, and have completely missed what we were discussing. Sorry if that's what happened...

Joined on Mon, Jun 27 2005
Full Member 251
"It's easy to see without looking too far that not much is really sacred." - Bob Dylan
rishonly  +  194014 Wed, 08 Feb 06 05:17 AM
 KYsheeplover06 wrote:

 Your accent is just what comes natural to you...

Very thoughtful points, KYsheep (Sorry, I am lazy to type lengthy names.Smile [:)]) One can  mimic the accent of a foreign language, but it can be never like the original accent.

Tearsofjoy  +  194019 Wed, 08 Feb 06 05:48 AM

Wow, you're a very mature just-15 year oldStick out tongue [:P], KYsheeplover! Yeah, sure, I'm definitely one to be talking at almost-17! Wink [;)]

You're quite right - accents are not meant to be copied. I pride myself on being able to do a pretty creditable mimic of the BBC accent(as well as a few others), but that's all it is - a mimic.

Fortunately though, with the advent of globalisation, English accents all over the world are growing more and more similar, as people from various nations continue to interact. I'm sure that within a decade or two, people will be surfing through "ancient" threads like these, and saying, "Accent? What are you talking about?" Smile [:)]

Cheers,

 - Joy

Rose [F]

adomi  +  194075 Wed, 08 Feb 06 10:01 AM
 KYsheeplover06 wrote:

 Perhaps I'm out on a limb on this subject, and have completely missed what we were discussing. Sorry if that's what happened...

That's not how I see it. You rather shed more light on it K, and I think we made one step toward answering the question of accent.

adomi  +  194080 Wed, 08 Feb 06 10:16 AM
 Tearsofjoy wrote:

I'm sure that within a decade or two, people will be surfing through "ancient" threads like these, and saying, "Accent? What are you talking about?" Smile [:)]

Cheers,

 - Joy

Rose [F]

I'm sorry to say that, as long as there will be different races and different languages, the question of accent will still exist, and threads such as this one will still be up-to-date, because generation after ours, will rise them. Globalisation will fail to overcome those kind of differences. I don't think any race in the world will ever give up on its languages.
Tearsofjoy  +  194229 Wed, 08 Feb 06 05:42 PM

I am sure that languages will never die out. However, with globalisation, I think that English speakers all over the world will be interacting to the extent that they all develop similar accents.

Already, with international calls becoming cheaper, voice chat software and English-language TV channels becoming available worldwide, more people can listen to American-accented English than before. It is true that this does not change their own accent, but it does serve to tone down regional accents. I think that with increased interaction, accents will become more and more similar to each other.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3607.32596. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.