We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


1 2 3 4 5
Share this topic:
This question is Not Answered
Latest post Sat, Nov 14 2009 9:15 PM by Anonymous. 39 replies.
Suggest an answer | | |
xHealthY  +  679970 Wed, 25 Feb 09 03:27 PM
Can someone explain me how to do this?

Here's an example

Someone does my taxes every April.
I have my taxes done every April





1. Someone is repairing my computer



2. My favorite mechanic at majesctic Motors checked my car.



Joined on Thu, Oct 30 2008
Full Member 213
Philip  +  679975 Wed, 25 Feb 09 03:36 PM
If you give it a try, we'll be glad to help you with any problems.
Joined on Thu, Jun 23 2005
Veteran Member 8,738
At reise er at leve! - H. C. Andersen
Yankee  +  679985 Wed, 25 Feb 09 04:10 PM
Hi xHealthY

I assume your teacher has probably told you that one basic format for this sort of thing is "have something done".  You can look at that as a "base" form.  When you use this format, you are basically saying that a Person A causes an unidentified Person B to do something.  In other words, A has something done (by B). Let's look at your first example:

- Someone does my taxes every April.  (B does my taxes every April.) The verb "do" is used in the simple present.

The only way that "someone" would do your taxes for you would be if you asked or told "someone" to do that.  Therefore, you cause "someone" to do your taxes for you.  "Someone" is non-specific Person B, and you are Person A in this case.

- I have my taxes done every April.  =  A causes B to do A's taxes every April.  The verb "have" is used in the simple present.


Now let's look at question 1:

1. Someone is repairing my computer.

The verb "repair" is used in the present continuous in that sentence, so you need to continue with that tense in the "have something done" version of the sentence.  In other words, you need to use "have" in the present continuous form":

1a. I am having my computer repaired

------------------------------------------------------------

2. My favorite mechanic at Majestic Motors checked my car.

Your second sentence is different from sentence 1 because in this case you are not referring to a non-specific "someone".  In this case the person who is doing the work is specified.

The usual format for this would be "have someone do something".  Did your teacher also mention this format to you?
Joined on Sat, Apr 15 2006
Connecticut, USA
Veteran Member 6,500
Amy "You can't depend on your eyes when your imagination is out of focus." - Mark Twain
xHealthY  +  679989 Wed, 25 Feb 09 04:19 PM
Okay I will give it try

1. Someone is repairing my computer
I have my computer repaired by someone.

2. My favorite mechanic at Majestic Motors checked my car.
 I have my car checked by my favorite mechanic at majestic motors.

3. Someone has just cleaned our windows.
I had my window cleaned by someone.

4. Someone is going to cut our grass.
He will have our grass cut.

5. Someone must paint our house
He have our house painted.

I know it wrong. :\
I need someone to teach how to do this

I know I need to find the  Subj+have/get+object+ main verb/pp ( by agent )
Yankee  +  679997 Wed, 25 Feb 09 04:40 PM

xHealthY
“1. Someone is repairing my computer.  (tense = present continuous)
I have am having my computer repaired by someone.

2. My favorite mechanic at Majestic Motors checked my car.  (tense = simple past)
 I have had my car checked by my favorite mechanic at majestic motors.

3. Someone has just cleaned our windows. (tense = present perfect, and the word "our" means you have to talk about "we")
I had my window cleaned by someone.
We have just had our windows cleaned.

4. Someone is going to cut our grass. (tense = "be going to" future, and the word "our" means you have to talk about "we")
He will have our grass cut.
We are going to have our grass cut.

5. Someone must paint our house. (modal word "must", and the word "our" means you have to talk about "we")
We must have our house painted.

Hi xHealthy
You seem to have the right idea, but you need to keep tenses and who is doing what in mind. 
So, keep practicing!

I guess your teacher has not told you about "have someone do something" yet.
xHealthY  +  680010 Wed, 25 Feb 09 05:18 PM
Lol , yeah I need practice. I don't want to fail . I have a test next week. ;/
but thx for the help

can you tell me about "have someone do something? lol
She did not had the time to tell us.
xHealthY  +  680015 Wed, 25 Feb 09 05:32 PM
Someone should check our electrical wiring.
We should have checked our electrical wiring.

Northtown contractors will probably do most of the work on our house
We will probably have our contractors do most of the work on the house

They might build a new porch for us too.
A new porch might be built for us by them.

Someone had better fix the neighbors roof.
"??" had better have fixed the neighbors roof.
Yankee  +  680017 Wed, 25 Feb 09 05:33 PM
Hi xHealthY

If your teacher has not mentioned "have someone do something", then maybe you shouldn't worry about that yet. Right now you should probably focus on and try to master what you need for your upcoming test. 

But don't be too surprised if you see the format "have someone do something" in a lesson sometime soon. Wink
(Sneak preview:  I had my favorite mechanic at Majestic Motors check my car.)

Yankee  +  680025 Wed, 25 Feb 09 05:53 PM

xHealthY
“Someone should check our electrical wiring.
We should have our electrical wiring checked our electrical wiring.

Northtown contractors will probably do most of the work on our house
We will probably have Northtown contractors do most of the work on the house

They might build a new porch for us too.
A new porch might be built for us by them
That is NOT a causative passive.  It is a just a normal passive sentence (and "by them" is unnecessary in the sentence).
The causative passive would have to begin with the word "We".  Can you figure it out yourself?
Causative:  We ....
(You need 6 more words after "We")

Someone had better fix the neighbors roof.
"??" had better have fixed the neighbors roof.
The neighbors had better have their roof fixed.
1 2 3 4 5
© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3614.32638. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.