We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


Share this topic:
This is a discussion thread.
Latest post Tue, Oct 11 2005 5:04 PM by Brk. 5 replies.
| |
Henrietta  +  146791 Tue, 11 Oct 05 11:04 AM

    Many, many years ago
    when I was twenty three,
    I got married to a widow
    who was pretty as could be,

    This widow had a daughter
    Who had hair of red.
    My father fell in love with her,
    And soon the two were wed.

    This made my dad my son-in-law
    And changed my very life.
    My daughter was my mother,
    For she was my father's wife.

    To complicate the matters worse,
    Although it brought me joy,
    I soon became the father
    Of a bouncing baby boy.

    My little baby then became  
    A brother-in-law to dad.
    And so became my uncle,
    Though it made me very sad.

   For if he was my uncle,
    Then that also made him brother
    To the widow's grown-up daughter
    Who, of course was my step-mother.

    Father's wife then had a son,
    Who kept them on the run.
    And he became my grandson,
    For he was my daughter's son.

    My wife is now my mother's mom.
    And it surely makes me blue.
    Because, although she is my wife,
    She is my grandma too.

    If my wife is my grandmother,
    Then I am her grandchild.
    And every time I think of it,
    It simply drives me wild.

    For now I have become
    The strangest case you ever saw

    As the husband of my grandmother,
   I am my own grandpa!

Joined on Mon, Aug 30 2004
Malta
Full Member 447
I took the liberty of fertilising your caviar
AYESHA  +  146805 Tue, 11 Oct 05 11:50 AM

Hello  Henrietta,

Oh my!!!

Where did you find this ? Actually this riddle is in one of the oldest Indian mythical book Vikramadithan and Betal(The name of  a king and the ghost that accompanies him)

Our professor has the original sanskrit scriptures and it was he who asked us the riddle.The question was "what was the relationship between the father's son and the son's son.The answer should not have any contradictions.I was hunting up for the answer,while I found this.Do you know the answer??? if yes please do tell it.

Joined on Sat, Oct 16 2004
INDIA
Full Member 118
Let peace be upon us all
Henrietta  +  146827 Tue, 11 Oct 05 02:24 PM

Hey Ayesha

This was emailed to me Smile [:)] Thought it might be a little fun for non-native speakers to figure out!

I don't know the answer to your question, sorry! But maybe if you drew a diagram it would help to solve it? You know, sort of like a family tree....

Henrietta  +  146830 Tue, 11 Oct 05 02:40 PM

I've thought about it for a while and it seems impossible to come up with an answer that has no contradictions!

The father's baby would be the step-brother of the son, so that would make the father's baby the uncle of of the son's baby. On the other hand, the father is married to the step-daughter of the son, which means that the father's baby would also be the grandchild of the son, making the son's baby the uncle of the father's baby! Its rather confusing, but I'm quite sure that there's no way you can come up with that answer without it having contradictions.... 

AYESHA  +  146863 Tue, 11 Oct 05 04:51 PM

Yes Henritta,

All our class students tried  making the family tree.But no one was able to find it and even the professor ceases to tell answer.We have challenged him that we would find the solution.If I find I would tell you.May be there is no solution at all!!

Here is a riddle which my mother invented based on this.

A lady is the grandmother to both a mother and a child.When will this be possible?

 

Brk  +  146866 Tue, 11 Oct 05 05:04 PM
Hey every1,

here is something strange for me in this riddle :
My wife is now my mother's mom.
And it surely makes me blue.
Because, although she is my wife,
She is my grandma too.

My wife is the mother of my mother-in-law that doesn't make her my grandma !!

What do u think ?

Take care
Brk
Brk
Joined on Fri, Jul 29 2005
New Member 09
© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3607.32596. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.