treat this as singular or plural?

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
Edamame  #484637  Mon, 03 Mar 08 08:11 PM
Hello all,

Could you tell me which is correct?

"More than 90% of the drugs are.. " or "More than 90% of the drugs is.."

Thank you very much. 

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Sun, Nov 5 2006
New User (09)
Marius Hancu  #484640  Mon, 03 Mar 08 08:12 PM
are: think proximity to drugs 
  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Apr 26 2006
Montreal, Canada
Forum Guru (11,235)
Proficient Speaker
ytsirk  #484647  Mon, 03 Mar 08 08:18 PM

Marius Hancu
are: think proximity to drugs 

Is that really a good answer? Shouldn't we teach people to think about the subject of the sentence when deciding on verb agreement? The subject of a sentence is never in a prepositional phrase like that. More is the subject, and more is plural. You always say "more are," not "more is."

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Thu, Feb 28 2008
Junior Member (48)
Kooyeen  #484658  Mon, 03 Mar 08 08:49 PM

ytsirk
The subject of a sentence is never in a prepositional phrase like that. More is the subject, and more is plural. You always say "more are," not "more is."


Hi,
I think it should be "are" because it agrees with "drugs". It's not true "more" is plural... if you had water instead of drugs, you would say that more than 50% of the water is polluted, wouldn't you? Water is uncountable, so you use a singular verb... Smile
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Dec 22 2005
Italy
Pre Guru (3,648)
Moderator
*Parental Advisory* Explicit Posts
Yoong Liat  #484659  Mon, 03 Mar 08 08:51 PM
Edamame
Hello all,

Could you tell me which is correct?

""More than 90% of the drugs are.. " or "More than 90% of the drugs is" or "More than 90% of the drugs is.."

Thank you very much. 

"More than 90% of the drugs are.. "  It should be 'are'. Half of the pupils were absent. "Half of the pupils" is definitely more than one pupil.

'More than 90% of the drugs' should be many  tablets, capsules, etc of the drugs. Therefore, you should use 'are'.

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Sep 4 2006
Singapore
Forum Guru (5,425)
Yoong Liat
ytsirk  #484668  Mon, 03 Mar 08 09:13 PM

Kooyeen
It's not true "more" is plural... if you had water instead of drugs, you would say that more than 50% of the water is polluted, wouldn't you? Water is uncountable, so you use a singular verb... Smile

I apologize for not qualifying my comment. In that sentence, more is plural. Yes it is.

  
Anonymous  #484671  Mon, 03 Mar 08 09:19 PM

ytsirk

Kooyeen
It's not true "more" is plural... if you had water instead of drugs, you would say that more than 50% of the water is polluted, wouldn't you? Water is uncountable, so you use a singular verb... Smile

I apologize for not qualifying my comment. In that sentence, more is plural. Yes it is.

 

I agree with ytsirk. Y'all need better examples though. "More" isn't a good example because it can be singular or plural depending on context.

But if you say something like "One of the apples is missing." Then you don't want to teach people to think about the proximity of apples, do you? The subject is "One" and so the verb is singular. If you teach someone to look at the word closest to the verb, they won't learn it correctly.

  
Edamame  #484676  Mon, 03 Mar 08 09:32 PM
Thank you all. I thought I might have to consider "more than 90% of the drugs" as one group. But in this case, it seems I can simply consider that the number of drugs mentioned here is more than 1; therefore, I should use "are."
  
Anonymous  #484680  Mon, 03 Mar 08 09:35 PM

Edamame
Thank you all. I thought I might have to consider "more than 90% of the drugs" as one group. But in this case, it seems I can simply consider that the number of drugs mentioned here is more than 1; therefore, I should use "are."

Yes. That way you'll be more correct more often than if you go with Marius' thought process.

  
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions