Two grammar questions...

   Share on Facebook  
Anonymous  #396829  Thu, 26 Jul 07 04:46 AM

Why can a pronoun be located in between a verb and adverb, but not between a verb and preposition? 

Can someone please both explain (a) and (f)?  How do I distinguish an adverb from the preposition?

For example,

a. Pick up it (INCORRECT)

b. Pick it up (correct)

c. Pick up the phone (correct)

d. Pick the phone up (correct)

Example two:

e. Looking at it (correct)

f. Looking it at (INCORRECT)

g. James handed in the report (the report is "it")  (correct)

h. James handed it in (it is "the report")  (correct)

  
CalifJim  #396882  Thu, 26 Jul 07 09:19 AM
You should read this Post:256204.  Here is just a part of it:

There are a number of particles (up, down, in, out, on, off, away, back) which should make us very suspicious that we are dealing with a separable phrasal verb, and a number of them (with, without, by, for, at, across, of, from, to, into) which almost certainly indicate a prepositional verb.  But there are some strange cases!
_____

<>a. Pick up it (INCORRECT)  Phrasal verb pick up.  Object it must precede up.
b. Pick it up (correct)
c. Pick up the phone (correct)
d. Pick the phone up (correct)

Example two:

<>e. Looking at it (correct)
f. Looking it at (INCORRECT)  Prepositional verb look at.  Object it must follow at.
g. James handed in the report (the report is "it")  (correct)
h. James handed it in (it is "the report")  (correct)

i.  James handed in it. (INCORRECT)  Phrasal verb hand in.  Object it must precede in.

CJ

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (16,975)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
Sooris  #396903  Thu, 26 Jul 07 10:13 AM

Hello,

A phrasal verb is made up of a verb and an adverb. You can have a pronoun between them. A phrasal verb acts as one unit. A pronoun coming between them will not change the meaning of the phrasal verb.

There is nothing wrong in having a pronoun between a verb and a preposition. But they are not one unit.

 Example: I saw him at the canteen.

But there is something called appropriate preposition. The verb will always take that particular preposition with which it always comes Example: abide by. Though the meaning of the verb doesn't change like the phrasal verb it doesn't allow a pronoun to come inbetween them.

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Sep 26 2006
chennai
Full Member (121)
Sureshbabu Padmanabahan
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service