Uncountable noun that is preceded by the "a"

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
Anonymous  #203334  Sun, 05 Mar 06 12:37 PM

My dictionary says that "kindness" is an uncountable noun with no mention of it being a variable noun.

That's where my Q lies. How can it be "a cruel kindness" with an article "a"?   

  
Clive  #203458  Sun, 05 Mar 06 07:47 PM

Hi,

I'd like to add a comment.

My dictionary defines kindness as 1. state or quality of being kind. 2. a kind act.

eg I believe that Confucius said 'Forget injuries, never forget kindnesses'.

eg There's an Irish saying 'May you have a thousand kindnesses'.

Having said the above, I do think that in certain cases where we are using meaning #1, we can say things like 'He has a cruel kindness in his character'. 'A' emphasizes the specificity and exceptionality of what we are focusing on.

Best wishes, Clive

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Oct 28 2004
Canada
Veteran Member (21,242)
ModeratorTeachers
El tango argentino es un pensamiento triste que se puede bailar (The tango argentino is a sad thought which can be danced) Enrique Santos Discépolo
Paco2004Fan  #206043  Tue, 14 Mar 06 07:18 AM

 Paco2004 wrote:
Mr Mic

But you know, probably I have only a decade or less to kick my bucket.

paco

Paco,

Please NEVER,NEVER,NEVER,NEVER, and NEVER say "kick my bucket". I am really upset on this. You are stupid to say such painful words.  I pray god that you will and should live atleast for next 10 more decades, helping Englishforums.

  
Not Ranked
Joined on Sat, Dec 31 2005
USA
New Member (11)
paco2004  #206058  Tue, 14 Mar 06 08:05 AM
 Paco2004Fan wrote:
Paco,

Please NEVER,NEVER,NEVER,NEVER, and NEVER say "kick my bucket". I am really upset on this. You are stupid to say such painful words.  I pray god that you will and should live atleast for next 10 more decades, helping Englishforums.

Thanks! If I live ten decades more, let's go together to the Moon to enjoy a Honey Moon!

paco 
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Wed, Nov 17 2004
Senior Member (4,095)
In Japan today even dogs are learning how to bow-wow in English.
Clive  #206128  Tue, 14 Mar 06 03:59 PM

Hi guys,

Idioms are tricky. You often have to use the exact wording to avoid sounding odd or unintentionally funny.

The idiom for this light-hearted expression is When I kick the bucket .... and not When I kick my bucket ...

Best wishes, Clive 

  
Diamondrg  #206144  Tue, 14 Mar 06 05:33 PM

 Paco2004 wrote:
Mr Mic

Yes you may be right. But you know, probably I have only a decade or less to kick my bucket.

paco

How old are you paco, if you don't mind? I have always considered you to be something between 25 and 35, but considering your remarks above, I think you are 60 or 70 and retired. You might have worked as an English teacher or your job might have involved such a lot of proficiency in English. Are my intuitions true?

  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Fri, Dec 2 2005
Turkey
Contributing Member (1,041)
paco2004  #206185  Tue, 14 Mar 06 09:05 PM
Hello Diamond

As I told elsewhere, I was disciplined as an expert to design facilities for water supply and sewage treatment. So my job has nothing to do with English, although I have helped people checking papers for an academic journal printed in Britain. My age? You can guess it. Maybe a little older than you. Smile [:)]

paco
  
Diamondrg  #206200  Tue, 14 Mar 06 09:59 PM

 Paco2004 wrote:
Hello Diamond

As I told elsewhere, I was disciplined as an expert to design facilities for water supply and sewage treatment. So my job has nothing to do with English, although I have helped people checking papers for an academic journal printed in Britain. My age? You can guess it. Maybe a little older than you. Smile [:)]

paco

How can I guess? I am 30. Then you are 35? If so, why do you think you have less than a decade. No one can know when he/she will die. Only God knows, if you believe in Him.

  
Believer  #266175  Wed, 13 Sep 06 12:16 AM

Thank you.

As you  seem to have said that in many case the speaker has the options and you gave several examples. I think.

Now, can you give me some examples of those cases where putting an indefinite article (ie, "a") in front of UNCOUNTABLE NOUNS would not be valid or be frown upon?

Thank you.     

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jan 2 2006
Contributing Member (1,969)
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service