We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!
Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com
This question is Not Answered
|
|
|
|
|
|
Guest
+
14123
Tue, 25 Nov 03 05:07 PM
Would this sentence be a correct use of a colon?
The three things I like to do on vacation are: swim in the ocean, shop at the mall, and play at the amusement park.
My English book says never a colon after a verb, but I was at a reading conference just last week and the presenter teaches a colon in the above example. Is this right or not?
|
|
|
|
|
whl626,
6 yr 1 days ago
What's wrong with the colon anyway ![Smile [:)]](/emoticons/emotion-1.gif)
|
|
|
|
|
|
ryan smith
+
14190
Wed, 26 Nov 03 03:26 AM
There is a mistake.
Keep in mind that the sentence has to make sense with the colon removed and one element of the list.
Corrections are below in CAPS:
"The ONE thing I like to do on vacation IS swimING in the ocean."
So, if we ignore the not-after-a-verb rule, your sentence should be: "...vacation are: swimming..., shopping..., and playing..."
Since the above sentence makes perfect sense WITHOUT the colon, why use it?
I've actually never heard of the rule that states you can't put a colon after a verb. However, if you treat the colon like an equals sign "=", then you don't need to remember such rules.
"I went: to the doctor's office, to the supermarket, and home." (Sounds funny and violates the verb rule).
"I went to three places: the doctor's office, the supermarket, and home." (Sound better. Three places = the doctor's office, the supermarket, and home).
Finally, how I would write your sentence:
"The three things I like to do on vacation are swimming in the ocean, shopping at the mall, and playing at the amusement park. "
Joined on
Tue, Sep 9 2003
CLASSIFIED
Full Member
199
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
advoca
+
14203
Wed, 26 Nov 03 07:55 AM
Forgive me jumping in.
The colon has only one important function: it indicates that what follows it is an explanation or elaboration or what precedes it.
What the precedes the colon must be a complete sentence. What follows it may be a sentence, a phrase, a list, or even a single word.
Here are some examples.
Only four contenders remain: Sampras, Agassi, Rafter and Henman.
We propose the creation of a new post: School Executive Officer.
Africa is facing a terrifying problem: AIDS.
The situation is clear: if you have unprotected sex with a stranger, you risk AIDS.
A colon should not interrupt a sentence that flows smoothly without it. Therefore, it is wrong to write, "The three things I like to do on vacation are: swim in the ocean, shop at the mall, and play at the amusement park." The colon is unnecessary.
A colon should never be used after the preposition 'like'.
No colon should follow the word 'including.'
Joined on
Fri, Oct 10 2003
New Member
28
|
|
|
|
|
Anonymous,
306 days ago
I have a BS in Communication Ed. and a MS in Literacy...for what it is worth, I was told never to use a colon after a verb.
Anonymous,
277 days ago
I have an MA in English. Do not use a colon after a verb. It should never separate the verb from the object.
|