We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


Share this topic:
This question is Not Answered
Latest post Mon, Jun 29 2009 9:08 PM by Avangi. 8 replies.
Suggest an answer | | |
MrPernickety  +  799610 Sun, 28 Jun 09 07:03 PM
Hi,

 

I've run into this sentence:

My thoughts are on track - a little one-lane highway granted, but they are on track

 

Could you tell me if I can put the bold part of the sentence this way: "Though it is a little one-lane highway"

 

Thanks !

Joined on Sat, Oct 25 2008
Regular Member 731
Amendment XXX to the US Constitution: No man shall be held accountable for any promise he makes while drunk unless it was a bet.
Soka  +  799621 Sun, 28 Jun 09 07:09 PM
MrPernickety
“Hi,


I've run into this sentence:

My thoughts are on track - a little one-lane highway, granted, but they are on track


Could you tell me if I can put the bold part of the sentence this way: "Though it is a little one-lane highway"


Thanks !

I guess you missed a comma over there.

My thoughts are on track ,though it is a little one-lane highway,but they are on track

 

Sounds perfect to my ears!

Joined on Mon, Dec 10 2007
Full Member 186
The Lord prefers common-looking people.That is why he makes so many of them.
Avangi  +  799659 Sun, 28 Jun 09 07:46 PM
Hi, Mr. Pernickety,


My ears balk a little bit at the double conjunction.  I think I could keep the "but" if it begins a new sentence.

Well, I suppose a semi would do the trick.

But, as S. shows, the dash must fall by the wayside when you add "though."


(I agree about the missed comma.)


Geez, how about writing the whole sentence out the way you intend?  The more I look at it the less sure I am about what you mean. 

Though it is a little one-lane highway, my thoughts are on track?  This would be okay.


Well, the problem with it is that reversing the order screws with the train of thought.  "My thoughts" might have another meaning.


Joined on Mon, Nov 19 2007
Veteran Member 8,180
". . . le plaisir delicieux et toujours nouveau d'une occupation inutile." - Henri de Regnier
RayH  +  799755 Sun, 28 Jun 09 09:13 PM
I'm with Anangi on this one, you need to clarify exactly what you mean to say.

Joined on Sat, Mar 22 2008
Contributing Member 1,555
Native speaker of U. S. English. Not a grammar expert.
MrPernickety  +  800264 Mon, 29 Jun 09 05:56 AM
Hi, guys,

Thanks for your replies !

 

Avangi

Geez, how about writing the whole sentence out the way you intend?  The more I look at it the less sure I am about what you mean”

 

 

In all fairness, the sentence at hand was not conceived by me, but by some author. I'm interested in the meaning of "granted". The whole sentence reads: My thoughts are on track - a little one-lane highway granted, but they are on track

 

I'm just wondering if I could rehash it this way:

 

My thoughts are on track, though it is a one-lane highway

 

In passing, are you saying that the sentence at issue is open to several interpretations ?

 

Thanks again !

RayH  +  801009 Mon, 29 Jun 09 04:15 PM
MrPernickety
“The whole sentence reads: My thoughts are on track - a little one-lane highway granted, but they are on track

Okay, I think I see what the author means. He is saying that his thoughts are like a "little one-lane highway", that is, presumably, not entirely clear, or fully formed. "granted" means "conceded" or "acknowledged" or "stipulated" or "admitted."


So, he is saying that even though he admits that his thoughts are not the best quality they are, at least, heading in the right direction.

Avangi  +  801026 Mon, 29 Jun 09 04:24 PM
The original sentence is clear to me.  It's a little bit cute, but I like it.


You may notice that Soeleen's rendering was quite different from your most recent version.  If we accept that your instructions would allow her version, then I'd say that your instructions are ambiguous.

I felt the whole thing could be clarified if you wrote out the version you were asking about.

Your new version works, but I'd keep the "little."  Without it, you miss the mark.


"Granted, X" = "I'll give you X"  =  "I'll admit X"  =  "albeit X"


She's a wonderful woman   -   granted, a bit ugly, but wonderful, nonetheless.


Edit.  Ray's synonyms are better!

MrPernickety  +  801162 Mon, 29 Jun 09 08:42 PM
Thanks for assistance!

 

Now I have an understanding of this word, not very good, granted, but enough to tide me over. ))

Avangi  +  801168 Mon, 29 Jun 09 09:08 PM
You're doing very well.


You might wish to think about the way the dash is used in your original excerpt.

Opinions differ on it's use, but I'm not sure the punctuation in you very last sentence will fly. 

It reads well, and is perfectly clear; but I think there's a limit to how much you can do with a comma.  Perhaps someone else can advise you.  I'm not very good with punctuation.

© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3607.32596. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.