Use of indefinite articles

   Share on Facebook  
Gori  #357835  Mon, 30 Apr 07 07:40 AM

I used to believe that, in general, I should use a singular countable noun with an article.  However, reading one book talking about articles, I started to get myself confused whether or not an article should be really omitted (= should not be used) in the cases as follows:

1. This one smells like old dog. (not "an old dog"?)
2. It tastes like apple./It tastes something like apple. (not "an apple"?)
3. You may put pineapple on your pizza.
4. Add carrot and onion after heating the pan.

Well, according to the author of this book, he says that "an article is not necessary if the noun specified is not recognized as having its original form."

As for the above 3 and 4, I kind of understand why "a/an" cannot be used--because we do not mean that we put/add a whole pineapple, carrot, or onion.  However, even so, I still have doubts if it is okay to leave the nouns (pineapple/carrot/onion) without any articles or making them plural instead.

Professional teachers/native speakers, please help me clear this problem.

  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Sep 5 2006
Tokyo
Junior Member (98)
Ant_222  #357944  Mon, 30 Apr 07 12:33 PM
To me, in all these examples singular nouns denote a substance rather than a thing. That's why indefinite articles are omitted.

P.S.: Anyway, I'd use "an old dog" for #1... because... it doesn't make much sense to speak of the substance (matter) of an old dog.
  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Sun, May 21 2006
Podolsk, Russia
Contributing Member (1,547)
Philip  #358067  Mon, 30 Apr 07 04:37 PM
 Ant_222 wrote:
To me, in all these examples singular nouns denote a substance rather than a thing. That's why indefinite articles are omitted. P.S.: Anyway, I'd use "an old dog" for #1... because... it doesn't make much sense to speak of the substance (matter) of an old dog.
I agree.
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jun 23 2005
USA Pacific Northwest (Seattle)
Veteran Member (6,181)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
At reise er at leve! - H. C. Andersen
Gori  #358307  Tue, 01 May 07 12:40 AM

So, do you mean that you would not use an article ("a/an") for #2 to #4 but would use it for #1?
Is it wrong if I used an article ("a/an") for #2 to #4?

  
Ant_222  #358476  Tue, 01 May 07 09:24 AM
«So, do you mean that you would not use an article ("a/an") for #2 to #4 but would use it for #1?»

Yes.

«Is it wrong if I used an article ("a/an") for #2 to #4?»

No, but the sentences would assume slightly different meanings. For example:

«Add a carrot and an onion after heating the pan.» — tells you to add exaxtly one carrot and one onion. Furtermore, one may understand that as adding whole (uncut) carrot and onion.



  
Gori  #358527  Tue, 01 May 07 12:44 PM
Thank you for your comments and information.
You have helped me a lot!
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service