Was or would have been?

   Share on Facebook  
jezabel  #86498  Mon, 04 Apr 05 07:58 AM
Hello, some days ago a native speaker didn't attend a meeting with
me because he was sick, then he sent me an email, one of whose
lines was:

"I hated to miss the meeting, but I don't think I was very helpful."

I felt really confused about this line.
Then I realized that he meant that, as he was sick,
if he had attended he wouldn't have been useful.

Being an esl student, I'm still confused about the right way of
saying this. Could help me with this?

Thanks a lot.
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Mon, Apr 4 2005
New Member (10)
just the truth  #86500  Mon, 04 Apr 05 08:03 AM
Hello, some days ago a native speaker didn't attend a meeting with
me because he was sick, then he sent me an email, one of whose
lines was:

"I hated to miss the meeting, but I don't think I was very helpful."

I felt really confused about this line.
Then I realized that he meant that, as he was sick,
if he had attended he wouldn't have been useful.

Being an esl student, I'm still confused about the right way of
saying this. Could help me with this?

==============

Hi Jezabel,

"would have been" seems the more sensible of the two but as I'm not privy to the complete context I can't say for sure. This person may have been referring to something else. If you ask anybody around here, they'll tell you that I always stress, "context context context". Language can be virtually opaque when you don't know the context.
  
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Dec 27 2004
Regular Member (849)
jezabel  #86689  Mon, 04 Apr 05 07:19 PM
Thanks just!
I am pretty sure about the meaning, and trying to explain the context
would be awkward, but I agree with you. I will specify the context next
time.
By the way, I've been surfing and looking at several fora before registering,
and this is my favorite by far.
  
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service