We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


Share this topic:
This question is Not Answered
Latest post Wed, Nov 15 2006 1:40 PM by Davidrock65. 6 replies.
Suggest an answer | | |
Davidrock65  +  292635 Mon, 13 Nov 06 06:32 PM

Dear teachers

I came across these in a novel that I'm reading :

" What'd you do? "and " Why'd you do that?"

A.  Is it commonly used in conversation and writing?

B.  Can I say or write " How'd he do that?" instead of "How did he do that?"  and "Why'd, When'd" instead of "Why did and When did?"

C. Is it fine if I say or write" What's he do for a living?" instead of " What does he do for a living?"  and "How's , Why's" instead of "How does and Why does?"

Thanks for answering my quesions

 

Joined on Wed, Apr 19 2006
taipei
Full Member 237
Philip  +  292639 Mon, 13 Nov 06 06:51 PM
 Davidrock65 wrote:

Dear teachers

I came across these in a novel that I'm reading :

" What'd you do? "and " Why'd you do that?"

A.  Is it commonly used in conversation and writing?

B.  Can I say or write " How'd he do that?" instead of "How did he do that?"  and "Why'd, When'd" instead of "Why did and When did?"

C. Is it fine if I say or write" What's he do for a living?" instead of " What does he do for a living?"  and "How's , Why's" instead of "How does and Why does?"

Thanks for answering my quesions

 

These contractions are very common in spoken AE.  I do not recommend them in writing, unless quoting someone's speech, as in a short story.
Joined on Thu, Jun 23 2005
Veteran Member 8,737
At reise er at leve! - H. C. Andersen
Goodman  +  292704 Mon, 13 Nov 06 11:35 PM
 Davidrock65 wrote:

Dear teachers

I came across these in a novel that I'm reading :

" What'd you do? "and " Why'd you do that?"

A.  Is it commonly used in conversation and writing?

B.  Can I say or write " How'd he do that?" instead of "How did he do that?"  and "Why'd, When'd" instead of "Why did and When did?"

C. Is it fine if I say or write" What's he do for a living?" instead of " What does he do for a living?"  and "How's , Why's" instead of "How does and Why does?"

Thanks for answering my quesions

 

" What'd you do? "and " Why'd you do that?"  - In sentences beginning with pronoun, it’s common to see “I’d prefer…. She’d consider….They’d rather wait…” etc.  The [‘d] is the contraction of “would”. 

A.  Is it commonly used in conversation and writing?  You will find this form of contraction commonly used. In my opinion, it’s fine, only when you can pronounce the subtle [‘d] sound in conversation.  

B.  Can I say or write " How'd he do that?" instead of "How did he do that?"  not why’d do that?” and "Why'd, When'd" instead of "Why did and When did?" - No, in this context, the [‘d] is not the contraction form for [would].  We can’t contract [did] the same way, nor can it be used this way.  We have to spell out [did] in spoken as well as written form completely. i.e. “why did he do that?”,

C. Is it fine if I say or write" What's he do for a living?" instead of " What does he do for a living?"  and "How's , Why's" instead of "How does and Why does?" No for the same explanation as above

Keep in mind, the experts (not self included) are from different parts of the English speaking world and may have contrasting views and opinion on the subject. This only represents what I know as correct.  Opinions welcome!Big Smile [:D]

 

 

Joined on Mon, Nov 7 2005
Senior Member 3,816
The name says it all!
Davidrock65  +  292822 Tue, 14 Nov 06 07:14 AM

Dear Goodman

Your opinion on this subject is highly valued.  However, I'm getting confused .

I often hear people say "What's he mean?" instead of "What does he mean?"

Here's an excerpt of a conversation in a novel I'm reading:

A: I have some good news

B: What?

A: My wife called me this morning.

B: What'd she say?

A: She said she stayed up all night thinking about us.

I think What'd she say represents What did she say in the dialogue.

Is the American usage on this different than the british one?

Goodman  +  293085 Tue, 14 Nov 06 06:32 PM

Often hear people say "What's he mean?" instead of "What does he mean?"

As I had indicated in my last post, if people do say "What's he mean?" the contracted [‘s] is pronounced fast in conversation.  I personally do not recommend the contracted [‘s] for [does] in this context application.  “What does he mean?” is the best form.   

Yankee  +  293098 Tue, 14 Nov 06 07:44 PM
Hi Davidrock65 and Goodman Wink [;)]

Native speakers contract all kinds of things in spoken English and this happens on both sides of the pond.  I'm American, so my answer refers specifically to American English.

" What'd you do? "and " Why'd you do that?" 

A.  Is it commonly used in conversation and writing?  It is extremely common in conversation. You should not use these types of contractions in written English.

B.  Can I say or write " How'd he do that?" instead of "How did he do that?"  and "Why'd, When'd" instead of "Why did and When did?"  These contractions are quite typical in spoken English.  You'll also hear things such as "wouldn't've" and "will've" and "there'll", etc Surprise [:O].   Do not use these contractions in written English.

C. Is it fine if I say or write" What's he do for a living?" instead of " What does he do for a living?" and "How's , Why's" instead of "How does and Why does?" YES to all for spoken English.  Do not use these types of contractions in written English.




Joined on Sat, Apr 15 2006
Connecticut, USA
Veteran Member 6,498
Amy "You can't depend on your eyes when your imagination is out of focus." - Mark Twain
Davidrock65, 3 yr 8 days ago

Thanks to all of you!!

© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3607.32596. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.