| Just because we have object him/them does not mean that "the corresponding interrogative or relative pronoun", must be used. |
|
True. So true, particularly because of the "must".
But in the context of a student question implicitly asking "What's all the fuss about 'who' and 'whom'?" I believe the student deserves some kind of easily grasped mnemonic/principle as an explanation, not just a dismissive "Don't bother with such stupidities", although frankly I am often tempted in that direction, as you surely recognize by my additional comments.
| And in everyday conversation, you are unlikely to hear being used with near the frequency that you'll hear . Wouldn't you agree, Jim? |
|
Come to California. Spend a month. Converse with as many people as you like. Take note of the number of times you hear "whom". I'll give you a dollar for each "whom" at the end of your stay. I doubt you'll have taxi fare to the airport for your trip back.
I think that pretty much answers whether I agree!
CJ
PS. Throw in a dollar for each "It is he" and "It is I". I don't think that taxi will go even another mile.