Will/Are

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
maj  #21869  Mon, 09 Feb 04 01:08 PM
-Will you ever let go of her
-Are you going to let go of her?

Any difference in meaning as far as intentions are concerned?
  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Mar 31 2003
Senior Member (4,756)
rommie  #21873  Mon, 09 Feb 04 01:23 PM
The only difference is the word "ever".

Without the "ever", there would have been no difference in meaning between:
1. Will you let go of her?
2. Are you going to let go of her?

With the "ever", there would have been no difference in meaning between:
1. Will you ever let go of her?
2. Are you ever going to let go of her?

But the "ever" itself does make a difference.

Rommie
  
Top 150 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jan 26 2004
Earth orbit
Regular Member (606)
EnglishFanatic  #21882  Mon, 09 Feb 04 02:34 PM
Hello all!

Is there no dirrerence only in this case or in general?

Thanks.
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Tue, Feb 3 2004
New Member (39)
rommie  #21887  Mon, 09 Feb 04 02:56 PM
This is a difference, but it's very, very subtle.

maj made things less clear by turning the words around to make questions, but as simple statements, "You will" and "You are going to" are completely interchangable. As questions, those phrases become "Will you" and "Are you going to". This is also true in the third person.

The subtle difference occurs only in the first person - I and we. It is this:

Compare these sentences.

1. I am going to fight.
2. I shall fight.
3. I will fight

In theory, (1) and (2) - NOT (1) and (3) - are completely equivalent, but (3) is an emphatic form. In the first person, don't say WILL unless you REALLY MEAN IT. Remember, this is only so in the first person.

(In the second and third person, use "will" for normal and "shall" for emphasis).

This distinction is not used much these days, particularly not in America.

Rommie.
  
EnglishFanatic  #21942  Tue, 10 Feb 04 02:29 AM
Thank you Rommie.
;)
  
mp  #22427  Sat, 14 Feb 04 01:13 AM
I think there is a difference in tone.

Will you ever let go of her? Is almost pleading; dramatic and femimine

Are you going to let go of her? Is abrupt; the tone is harsher.

If either sentence is written as part of a longer work, then the choice should be matched with the character asking the question.
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Fri, Nov 14 2003
New Member (12)
pedant  #22443  Sat, 14 Feb 04 07:36 AM
"Ever" suggests an infinite span of time, or at least a lifetime. Without "ever" the implication is that the letting go will be soon.
  
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Dec 18 2003
Full Member (104)
maj  #22455  Sat, 14 Feb 04 10:21 AM
Thank you pedant, I really think your explanation is very enlightening. How would you answer these questions, though?
  
dinosm  #22492  Sun, 15 Feb 04 02:21 PM
Regarding future tense structures, 'will' implies a wish, a willingness to do something.

"I will fight" means that I really want to fight and that's what I am going to do.

"I'm going to fight" denotes a future event but does not imply the same willingness as 'will' in the previous example (at least that's how I've come to understand it).

What we learn in language school is that the present continuous tense provides the strongest form of speaking about the future.

"I am fighting this guy" means I will definitely, absolutely, beyond any doubt fight this guy, no matter what.
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Fri, Nov 28 2003
Manchester, U.K.
New Member (43)
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service