We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


Share this topic:
This question is Not Answered
2 Followers
Latest post Sat, Nov 7 2009 2:03 AM by uktous. 8 replies.
Suggest an answer | | |
uktous  +  962756 Thu, 05 Nov 09 08:52 PM
hi,
will the "comma" changed the meaning of the sentences?


Sentence1

I explained the questions in the exercise sheet during the first half of the class and then students would practise the questions during the second half of the class.

VS

I explained the questions in the exercise sheet during the first half of the class and , then, students would practise the questions during the second half of the class


Sentence 2

The new arrangement was that during the first 50 minutes students work on their exercises and I answer all questions one by one at the same time, whereas during the last 10 minutes I explained some most popular questions to all students

VS

The new arrangement was that, during the first 50 minutes, students work on their exercises and I answer all questions one by one at the same time, whereas, during the last 10 minutes, I explained some most popular questions to all students

Joined on Mon, Oct 26 2009
Junior Member 99
This is a live chat room, hosted on the chat page. You can also click here to see the chat in fullscreen.
DeepSouthRick  +  962923 Fri, 06 Nov 09 12:54 AM
Both comma uses are incorrect. They should be:

 

I explained the questions in the exercise sheet during the first half of the class, and then students...

 

 

The new arrangement was that during the first 50 minutes students work on their exercises and I answer all questions one by one at the same time; whereas, during the last 10 minutes I..

 

 

 

Rick

Joined on Thu, Nov 5 2009
New Member 11
uktous  +  962986 Fri, 06 Nov 09 02:28 AM
difficult for me...


someone told me that the texts between 2 commas could be ingnored so


The new arrangement was that, during the first 50 minutes, students work on their exercises and I answer all questions one by one at the same time, whereas, during the last 10 minutes, I explained some most popular questions to all students


=


The new arrangement was that students work on their exercises and I answer all questions one by one at the same time, whereas I explained some most popular questions to all students


clearly, the second sentence has problem

Anonymous, 15 days ago
Hi. I liked your response. Would you please tell me if we could put commas around an appositive or non-essential element, or something like an extra information part between an essential clause and an object of its reference? (I am not sure I said correctly what I wanted to say, though.) I have underlined the part I think is the essential element

 

eg,

There is a boy, who looks sleepy, tossing a coin into the air.

 

How about this? Is this correctly punctuated? I don't know what is the part underlined, though.

 

I saw a boy, who looks sleepy, tossing a coin into the air.

uktous  +  963027 Fri, 06 Nov 09 03:59 AM
in my limited understanding your use of comma is correct


however, in my understanding (which may be wrong), you are better to write "to toss" rather than tossing




thanks

DeepSouthRick  +  963479 Fri, 06 Nov 09 03:16 PM
uktous
“in my limited understanding your use of comma is correct

 


however, in my understanding (which may be wrong), you are better to write "to toss" rather than tossing




thanks

 

I agree... you seem to have a good understanding of how to use commas in this sentence.

 

However, it's incorrect to use "to toss" instead of "tossing" in your sample sentences.

 

 

Rick

uktous  +  963645 Fri, 06 Nov 09 07:54 PM
hi, Rick


I saw a boy, who looks sleepy, to toss a coin

=

I saw a boy to toss a coin



why it is incorrect?

the sentence should be grammatically correct


DeepSouthRick  +  963842 Sat, 07 Nov 09 12:49 AM
Why do you think it should be correct?

 

In this sentence, the verb "toss" does not need the article, "to."

 

Example of using "to toss":

 

"He wants to toss a coin."

 

"I told him to toss a coin."

 

 

 

 

 

uktous  +  963874 Sat, 07 Nov 09 02:03 AM
then i think


i saw a boy tossing a coin


a bou tossing a coin is a noun phrase



so..tossing a coin is right

© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3607.32596. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.