We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!
Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com
This question is Not Answered
|
|
|
|
|
|
Guest
+
10064
Tue, 07 Oct 03 06:46 AM
You say:
1-Every time I drink coffee I get a stomach ache.
2-Should every time I drink coffee I get a stomach ache?
3-Should every time he drinks coffee he get a stomach ache?
4-Should he drink coffee he gets a stomach ache?
5-Should every time he drink coffee, he get a stomach ache?
I realize the word-order is slightly unusual, as 'every time' should come at the end of these sentences. Nevertheless it is syntactically correct.
The question is, then, which is correct 3's 'drinks' or 5's 'drink'?
Thanks--walansari@hotmail.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ryan smith
+
10068
Tue, 07 Oct 03 08:17 AM
#3 sounds the best, although the word order in 2-5 is very confusing.
I say #3 because when I rearrange the words I get this:
"Should he get a stomach ache every time he drinks coffee?"
Still, why use "should" when you can use "does"?
"Does he get a stomach ache every time he drinks coffee?" sounds much, much better.
Joined on
Tue, Sep 9 2003
CLASSIFIED
Full Member
199
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Lib
+
10069
Tue, 07 Oct 03 08:37 AM
IMHO neither 3 nor 5 is correct. In these sentences 'every time' is redundant because 'should' implies 'every time'. The best one is 4. After 'should' the verb goes in infinitive (drink). However, the other verb (get) should have the present tense 's'.
By the way, the sentence is not a question, so the question mark shouldn't be there.
Joined on
Tue, Sep 23 2003
New Member
13
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ryan smith
+
10078
Tue, 07 Oct 03 10:29 AM
It is a question. It may be rhetorical.
Should X happen to me every time I do Y?
Should I get arrested every time I commit a crime?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Lib
+
10172
Wed, 08 Oct 03 09:06 AM
I don't think the sentences refer to the 'morality'or 'advisability(??)' of getting a stomachache. I think the poster is referring to a type of inversion used with 'should'. It is similar to conditional clauses (usually with so-called first conditionals):
If I see him, I'll tell him you called = Should I see him, I'll tell him you called.
What about this one?
Everytime I go out without an umbrella, it rains. or
Should I go out without an umbrella, it rains.
It does sound rather strange to me, but I think this is the idea the original poster was getting at; 'should' meaning 'every time'.
What do you think?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
moijelesuis
+
10240
Wed, 08 Oct 03 05:59 PM
i agree doubly with lib, both on his interpretation of the original post as well as his response that it sounds a bit stilted. (again, punctuation has caused the confusion ... the "poster" should not have put question marks after each sentence, just after his initial question!)
Joined on
Sat, Aug 16 2003
usa/canada
Full Member
116
|
|
|
|
|
Guest,
6 yr 50 days ago
This is the original poster, walansari@hotmail.com. Thank you all for responding.
Yes, 4 should not have had a question mark. But you all lost track of my original question. And I think I figured this one out. But before I congratulate myself on genius, please tell me this makes sense.
The problem is
1-Should he remember his country, he cries.
2-If he remembers his country, he cries.
3-Whenever he remembers his country, he cries.
These all mean the same thing. Namely, that they all mean ‘every time’.
So, to combine ‘every time’ in one of the sentences above confuses the sense of the sentence; unless a comma is added.
Whenever he remembers his country, he cries, every time.
This much is easy to figure out. The problem arose from the fact that “Should” has two senses: the conditional and the interrogative.
If you say,
Should this happen every time (an interrogative)
Should this happen (more likely a conditional).
Should every time this happen(s) (confused: this much was clear to your native ears, but not mine).
I think the rest is now clear. And again, thank you all.
|