"She is the only woman in the candidates that/who can speak Japanese."

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
Grammar Geek  #427440  Fri, 05 Oct 07 03:10 PM
 Neeraj Jain wrote:

What about this sentence?

She is the only woman candidate who can speak Japanese.

This is clear, if you want to say that there are other women candiates, but those other women don't speak Japanese. As I keep saying, it's ambiguous without a rewrite, which is why (aside from preferring "who" to "that") I don't find that Marius's alleviates the ambiguity.

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Tue, Jan 10 2006
Pennsylvania, USA
Veteran Member (15,567)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
Barbara, who answers in American English.
Kooyeen  #427577  Fri, 05 Oct 07 08:22 PM
 Teleostomi wrote:

It's interesting as Kyoeen said that "who" and "that" could be taken to refer to either woman or to candidates, but it would generally be understood to refer to woman.



Hmmm, no, I didn't say that. I said I would think it referred to "woman". There was no context, so when there's no context I usually make up one. Smile [:)]

  
Top 25 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Dec 22 2005
Italy
Senior Member (3,973)
Moderator
If you don't have a sense of humor already, it's about time you buy one.
CalifJim  #427655  Sat, 06 Oct 07 03:07 AM
The choice between that and who does not change the meaning.
In either case there is ambiguity between whether the relative pronoun (that or who) refers back to woman or candidates.  My first impulse is to take it as woman.

In practical terms, however, it doesn't make any difference.  The same woman is identified as the only one whether she is the only female who speaks Japanese or the only Japanese speaker who is female.

Graphically, it doesn't matter whether we eliminate the non-Japanese speakers first (X row) and then the males, or whether we eliminate the males first (M column) and then the non-Japanese speakers, we still end up in the square which represents female Japanese speakers, and there is only one of those.

               M            F

J                      |     1
             ____________
X                    
                       |

CJ

  
Top 10 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Aug 2 2004
California
Veteran Member (16,964)
ModeratorProficient Speaker
"There are no facts, only interpretations" - Nietzsche
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service