Is it "well written" or "well-written"?

1 2
   Share on Facebook  
Ryanz0r  #194252  Wed, 08 Feb 06 06:35 PM
Hi everyone! I came across this forum upon searching for an answer to this query I have. I've always believed it to be "well written" because "well" is an adverb simply describing the passive adjective "written," where hyphenation is only necessary if an adjective is describing another adjective ("open-minded" for instance). However, I see "well-written" very frequently, and it seems to be the more widely accepted convention.

Can anyone shed some light on this? Thanks in advance. Smile [:)]
  
Not Ranked
Joined on Wed, Feb 8 2006
Torquay, England
New Member (19)
Me have the grammar bad!
rishonly  #194267  Wed, 08 Feb 06 06:59 PM

 Ryanz0r wrote:
Hi everyone! I came across this forum upon searching for an answer to this query I have. I've always believed it to be "well written" because "well" is an adverb simply describing the passive adjective "written," where hyphenation is only necessary if an adjective is describing another adjective ("open-minded" for instance). However, I see "well-written" very frequently, and it seems to be the more widely accepted convention.

Can anyone shed some light on this? Thanks in advance. Smile [:)]

My two cents:

If the compound adjective ("well written") precedes a noun, use a hyphen. If  the elements--for example,"well" and "written"-- come after a noun, don't use the hyphen.

This is a well-written article. 

This article is well written.  

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Sat, Mar 5 2005
KUMBAKONAM,INDIA
Contributing Member (1,781)
Moderator
Regards, Krish
Anonymous  #194301  Wed, 08 Feb 06 08:26 PM

Hi,

I will give it a shot....

This novel is well written – passive, “well” modifies “written”.

 

This is a well-written novel- "Well-written" now is used as adjective to describe the novel. Note it that a hyphen is typically used in this form.

 

This is a piece of "badly-damaged" furiture. No one will buy it.- hyphenated as adj.

The piece of furiture is "badly damaged". No one will buy it.- adverb modifying verb

  
Ryanz0r  #194305  Wed, 08 Feb 06 08:36 PM
Hmm, that indeed seems acceptable, but I still fail to understand why an adverb and adjective must become a hyphenate. Tongue Tied [:S] Is it simply a bizarre exception that we have to conform to? It is perfectly fine to have "a brilliantly written article," so why not "well" instead of "brilliantly" (as an example)?
  
rishonly  #194311  Wed, 08 Feb 06 08:59 PM

 Ryanz0r wrote:
Hmm, that indeed seems acceptable, but I still fail to understand why an adverb and adjective must become a hyphenate. Tongue Tied [:S] Is it simply a bizarre exception that we have to conform to? It is perfectly fine to have "a brilliantly written article," so why not "well" instead of "brilliantly" (as an example)?

Because the hyphenation rule that we are talking doesn't apply for adverbs that end with "ly".

(E-x)

1. They are thoroughly tested materials. (Not, thoroughly-tested)

2. The remarkably hot day suddenly turned into a remarkably rainy day.(Not remarkably-hot day and remarkably-rainy day)

  
Ryanz0r  #194312  Wed, 08 Feb 06 09:04 PM
Aha! So "well" is irregular for more than the fact that it does not end "ly" as the majority of adverbs do? That solves my predicament, thanks very much! Smile [:)]
  
rishonly  #194313  Wed, 08 Feb 06 09:07 PM

 Ryanz0r wrote:
Aha! So "well" is irregular for more than the fact that it does not end "ly" as the majority of adverbs do? That solves my predicament, thanks very much! Smile [:)]

NP.Smile [:)]

  
Believer  #250526  Sun, 30 Jul 06 06:37 PM

Thank you.

Would you definitely say that the following underlined part in the sentence of yours needs to be hyphenated because I think it might not be?

This is a piece of "badly-damaged" furniture. No one will buy it. 

  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Mon, Jan 2 2006
Contributing Member (1,969)
milky  #250531  Sun, 30 Jul 06 06:46 PM
Use the hyphen.
  
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on Thu, Jan 15 2004
Senior Member (3,149)
Hume said that if we had perfect or complete descriptive knowledge of reality, we could not, by reasoning, derive a single valid "ought".
1 2
AddThis Feed Button RSS Feed: ESL General English Grammar Questions
© 2008 MediaCET Ltd.
Terms and Conditions & Terms of Service