We have partnered with TradePub to bring you free industry magazines and resources - no coupons or credit cards required!

Visit: englishforums.tradepub.com


1 2
Share this topic:
This is a discussion thread.
Latest post Sat, Jan 26 2008 4:03 PM by Usenet. 15 replies.
| |
Elroy Willis    802685 Thu, 24 Jan 08 08:01 PM

Hi,
I was watching the show "Urban Legends" on Bio channel the other night and saw that they used a story I wrote a few years ago which became an urban legend. The original short news story got passed around in email, etc, and ended up on TV, eventually.
Here's a Youtube link for it:
nmReSI
The original story I wrote is referenced here:
http://www.snopes.com/religion/plastic.asp
A few things were changed in the Bio channel's version of it, but it's clear that they used my story, and I wonder what I might do about it, in several different regards.
If Bio Channel tries to hit me with copyright infringement, for my Youtube video, I think I would actually like that to happen, so I can get in contact with their lawyers...
What would others around here do, in my situation?

Elroy Willis
www.elroysemporium.com
Jacques E. Bouchard    802701 Thu, 24 Jan 08 08:23 PM

@reader2.panix.com:
"If Bio Channel tries to hit me with copyright infringement, for my Youtube video, I think I would actually like that to happen, so I can get in contact with their lawyers..."

They'll just write a letter to YouTube, who will then close your account and never reply to your e-mail. It's just one more middleman to muddle the issue.
jaybee
Elroy Willis    802702 Thu, 24 Jan 08 08:31 PM

"If Bio Channel tries to hit me with copyright infringement, ... happen, so I can get in contact with their lawyers..."

"They'll just write a letter to YouTube, who will then close your account and never reply to your e-mail. It's just one more middleman to muddle the issue."

But I feel I have the right to store the video on my own site, and pass the link around, without any copyright problems, don't you think?

http://www.elroysemporium.com/videos/dashboardjesus.mpeg

If Bio Channel confronts me about the above video, then I can pursue things from there. I don't feel worried about violating any copyrights, since I think I have the upper hand, so to speak...

Elroy Willis
www.elroysemporium.com
Alan Brooks    802715 Thu, 24 Jan 08 08:49 PM

"I was watching the show "Urban Legends" on Bio channel the other night and saw that they used a story ... to happen, so I can get in contact with their lawyers... What would others around here do, in my situation?"

I think your urban legend story is a very interesting case.

You definitely wrote it, and so have a copyright on it. But you also wrote it originally for distribution to newsgroups, which I think introduces some ambiguities.Take this with a grain of non-lawyerly salt, as IANAL. But newsgroups are not the same as e-mail and they're not the same as a web site. If you published first to a website, I think your work would be treated much as any published work, and the copyright office would recognize your first date of creation as the date it appeared on your web page, and people would have to pay you to re-use the story. In other words, a website is treated sort like a newspaper.

If, however, you had "published" your story by sending in to some individual as e-mail, you would own the copyright but the recipient of the e-mail would own their copy of your work, and would (generally) be free to use it as they wish. That's why when you read the published letters of some famous author they often contain the reply letters from their correspondents: because the famous author owns the copy of the letter sent to them.
So, when something is published on a newsgroup, is it more like being published on a web page or more like being sent out to a set of recipients as a sort of group e-mail? If the latter, then I think you lose some rights. But I suspect that this has never been fully addressed by the copyright office and/or the courts. And maybe I'm completely wrong, because, of course, IANYL or anyone else's lawyer either.

But one thing I do know is that if you do want to claim copyright, then you must defend your copyright when you see it violated. Nothing says you don't own a copyright like watching passively as somebody copies your work. If you feel someone has tread on your ownership and you sit around waiting for them to sue *you*, it will appear to the courts that you did not feel a violation took place.
At the very least I would draft a letter of complaint to the Bio Channel saying that your material was used without credit or compensation. Put them on notice that there are ownership issues.
Alan Brooks

A with an Underwood
Drop-kick me Jesus...
MWSM FAQ: http://www.panix.com/~mwsm/faq.html
Filtering Trolls: http://www.panix.com/~mwsm/trolls.html
Jacques E. Bouchard    802716 Thu, 24 Jan 08 08:52 PM

"They'll just write a letter to YouTube, who will then ... e-mail. It's just one more middleman to muddle the issue."

"But I feel I have the right to store the video on my own site, and pass the link around, ... there. I don't feel worried about violating any copyrights, since I think I have the upper hand, so to speak..."

You're right, but YouTube isn't going to ask your permission before closing your account, and neither are they going to give you a reason or reply to your e-mail. That means having your lawyers dealing with YouTube just so they can get to the Bio channel and eventually deal with *them*. It's an extra step of legalese, extra delays and extra fees for nothing, really, since YouTube can't be held liable in any of this.
jaybee
Jacques E. Bouchard    802717 Thu, 24 Jan 08 08:58 PM

"At the very least I would draft a letter of complaint to the Bio Channel saying that your material was used without credit or compensation. Put them on notice that there are ownership issues."

Oh great, between greedy WGA members striking and greedy copyright holders suing, what's left to watch for us poor slobs?
jaybee
Jacques E. Bouchard    802730 Thu, 24 Jan 08 09:01 PM

"You're right, but YouTube isn't going to ask your permission before closing your account, and neither are they going to ... of legalese, extra delays and extra fees for nothing, really, since YouTube can't be held liable in any of this."

You could try, however, to pre-empt cancellation by putting a disclaimer at the beginning of your YouTube video (and in the description). But the fact remains that while you wrote the original story, the production of it remains the Bio channel's, so *no one* can use it.
jaybee
Alan Brooks    802731 Thu, 24 Jan 08 09:10 PM

"At the very least I would draft a letter of ... compensation. Put them on notice that there are ownership issues."

"Oh great, between greedy WGA members striking and greedy copyright holders suing, what's left to watch for us poor slobs?"

Well, you could try these:
K7E
Alan Brooks

A with an Underwood
Check it out, this
butter in my mouth
won't melt.
MWSM FAQ: http://www.panix.com/~mwsm/faq.html
Filtering Trolls: http://www.panix.com/~mwsm/trolls.html
Skipper    802732 Thu, 24 Jan 08 09:13 PM

"At the very least I would draft a letter of ... compensation. Put them on notice that there are ownership issues."

"Oh great, between greedy WGA members striking and greedy copyright holders suing, what's left to watch for us poor slobs? jaybee"

Barney
1 2
© MediaCet Ltd. 2009, v5.0.3614.32638. All content posted by our users is a contribution to the public domain, this does not include imported usenet posts.*
For web related enquires please contact us on webmaster@mediacet.com, status updates are available at status.mediacet.com.
*Usenet post removal: Use 'X-No-Archive'. You may not have understood that your posts would end up in the public domain. Please send proof of the poster's email, we will remove immediately.