So these sentences are ok then Yes. They're fine. A since -clause simply limits the time period (ending at the present moment, as usual) in which the event occurred, so it's always acceptable to use a since -clause with a present perfect

So these sentences are ok then Yes. They're fine. A since -clause simply limits the time period (ending at the present moment, as usual) in which the event occurred, so it's always acceptable to use a since -clause with a present perfect

Here is a penny for thought: My family has owned the business for 20 years. This says my family started the business 20 years ago and still has ownership. If this grammatical reasoning stands, "I have lived in Paris" by itself is an

Short answer: Yes, but i'm not as likely to use it that way. Opti is the faster typist - he posted 2 minutes before I did! Maybe he'll give his opinion too, but if someone said "I've been sick" (remember in the

it is an action verb, which justifies the use of have in simple past as a substitution of present perfective in American English Please explain why this might be so. I see no relationship between the two uses. The sentence under consideration

Hey, just finished this exercise, but was a little unsure about my answers. I'd be grateful if anyone could offer me a little marking expertise :) Cheers, Matt. 1. When I arrived at the station, the train had gone. - PAST PERFECT 2. Have

What about "She said she went to America 10 years ago?" The same logic applies. It doesn't matter if you say "went", "had gone", or "had been". The meaning of ago and before doesn't change.

Further question: You meantion: She said she had been to America 10 years ago. = She said she had been to America August 1, 1999. What about " She said she went to America 10 years ago,?" Is that correc tto say "she said

I think some past perfect tense uses indicate not what happened in the past but what had been happening upto the moment of some action or incident (or something, I am not sure) and the past perfect tense "had been" seems to do that, that

'have had' is the present perfect construction which, in this case, expresses result. Therefore, we call it the resultative present perfect tense – the result being that employees are left with positive feelings, or a positive working