You searched for the word(s): user:Hoogard (39 record(s) found in 0.33s.)
-
well. if he isn't aware of it it could med problems. It also depends on what you really call "the truth". Cause if it's the absolute truth we would tell it even if he isn't aware of the fact himself. But now we're int philosphy. And i do agree with you that this based upon he himself knowing when...
-
Let's make this simple.
You ask him:
If there came another person after me and asked for the way to life. Which way would you indicate him to go?"
Case A:
He will tell you the truth. And the truth is that he will lie to the next person coming there. Hence you don't want to take the road he's...
-
well. the thing is, you don't have to know if he's lying or telling the truth. The only thing you have to know is he will tell the next person the opposite.
Based on this you can formulate a question that leads you to the conclusion to go opposite the way he tells/shows you to go regardless if...
-
and asnwering a question is, which he is known for doing, is something completely diffirent from joining you on a hike, wouldn't you agree?
I could state, and rightly argue for it that your suggestion is a request and not really a question. The question "can you walk with me the way to life"...
-
and your point would certainly be well taken if there was anybody around here who has posted a riddle and added stipulations afterwards. Now, since i haven't dont that you still haven't made your point.
-
and your point is? or can you take that again in english?
-
except that it is given that he according to legend answers one of your questions. And lies every second time and tells the truth the other times. It is obviously not known to legend that he leads anyone who wants to the road of life.
And even so, you can't naturally assume he won't lead you to...
-
You're just forgetting the fact that he doesn't have to go with you anywhere.
-
I don't get this. Are you people having a hard time reading the first page? Cause the solution as given there so there's no need to keep talking about unless you necesserily want to that is...
-
yes. it's on the first page. Posted: 12-15-2004 08:37 PM.
Don't you read through the thread?
-
