This is a discussion thread · 17 replies
It seems that if you apply the definition of "opposed" that the two items are in opposition to one another the first would work but it also seems correct to use "apposed" if you are doing a comparison.
"I prefer coffee as opposed to tea" or "
I usually hear "in apposition to." I fear your sentence stretches the definition.
How about, I was surprised by the apposition of coffee and tea in front of him. ??
Looking for ESL work?: Try our EFL / TOEFL / ESL Jobs Section!
Anonymous "I prefer coffee as opposed to tea" or "I prefer coffee as apposed to tea"This sounds weird to my ears. Prehaps: Q: Would you like some hot tea ? A: "I'd prefer coffee than/ over tea, if you don't mind ".
But: John will be back to work Wednesday from vacation as opposed to Friday as originally scheduled.
As opposed ~ means contrary to or in conflict with.
A: Would you care for some coffee?
B: I prefer coffee over/as opposed to tea, but frankly, I could go for a martini.
Granted, it's a bit wordy, and perhaps impolite.
AvangiI see no problem with "I prefer coffee as opposed to tea."Hahaha Avangi, I think you already have one too many Martini[D]
Seriously, "as opposed" sounded too heavy for the context to me. Maybe I should have one of those Martinis that you enjoy.
As you have noticed from the previous posts, the phrase 'as apposed to' simply is not idiomatic. You need only check COCA (Corpus of Contemporary American English) to find that out. There are no examples whatsoever for any usage of 'as apposed to', but there are approximately 6500 examples for 'as opposed to'.
Dimsum, this also sounds odd:
"I'd prefer coffee than tea, if you don't mind ".
For me, 'than' would have to be preceded by the word 'rather' in that sentence in order to be grammatical, and to sound natural.
I agree with Avangi that "I prefer coffee as opposed to tea" is OK. It just isn't the most common way to express that idea.
YankeeDimsum, this also sounds odd:Thanks Amy for pointing that out. I should have a separate example with "than" instead of mixing it with "over" in the same context.
YankeeI agree with Avangi that "I prefer coffee as opposed to tea" is OK. It just isn't the most common way to express that idea.
Avangichampion of the most commonUgh. Who would want that title anyway??
People are waiting to help.
Related forum topics: