+1

One of the uses of the present perfect is to express a complain or criticism. It is also used if something has been happening regularly. The present perfect is used if something has happened once or a number of times.

My question is: If something happened once, but I am angry about it, can I use the present perfect continuous? For example: someone has urinated in my garden when drunk at a party. Can I say: "Have you been urinating in my garden?".

I have a feeling that if I use the present perfect simple, it doesn't sound as irritated or cross.

+0
Comments  
Students: We have free audio pronunciation exercises.

You would absolutely say "have you been urinating in my garden" When you use the continuous tense you are concentrating on the action and not the result of the action (which is what the present perfect simple concentrates on). Here you are annoyed about the action which isn't happening at the moment but before now. So it is absolutely logical to use the present perfect continuous. It describes an action before now. If you are interested in clearing up all your questions about the tenses there is a website which could help you. www.laclefanglaise.com/teachers-zone.html