This question has been answered · 5 replies
Anonymous:i have seen that movie or i saw that movie? What's the difference between them? When to use them?
Approved answer (verified by Mister Micawber)
What's the difference between them? When to use them?
Here are some examples with a very basic explanation .
Tom: Hi, Bob, do you want to go and see Mission Impossible?
Bob: No, thanks, I have seen that movie. Bob is talking about a past event but, really, he is thinking about now. Now, he doesn't want to go.
Tom: Hi, Bob, they were showing Mission Impossible at the movie theatre last month. Did you go?
Bob: Yes, I saw that movie. Here, Bob is just thinking and talking about past events, not about the present.
I suggest you should review the Present Perfect in your grammar book.
Best wishes, Clive
Anonymous:I'm still interested! I have looked in every grammar book
that I have and I am still confused!
Why can't you say " I saw that movie" or " I have seen that movie. Why can't both be correct?
Do you always have to use a specific time with the simple past?
How did you get there?
I took a cab.
Did you see your brother?
Yes, I saw him.
I understand you use the present perfect with an unspecified time in the past but can't you use present perfect too?
Have you seen your brother?
Yes, I have seen my brother.
Do you always have to use a specific time with the simple past?-- No, not at all; the point is that a specific past time makes present perfect impossible.
I think there is a bit difference between the two sentences
"I have seen" mean either you saw the person or things for more than one time or mean you saw a person or thing for along time from past to present. thus, "I saw" mean for one time and in specific time.
I was see that movie on Sunday. (specific time).
I have seen that movie (two, three or many time .... until now)
Anonymous:Great explanation...Thank you man...I used to say: I have saw in many times...now I understood that I was wrong..tks again..
People are waiting to help.
Related forum topics: