•  12
  •  10,423
Change the type of thread
+0
Hello! Could someone else explain the difference between 'in' and 'within' about time?

eg1 This is the worst water shortage in 4 years.

eg2 This is the worst water shortage within 4 years.

Thanks in advance!
1 2
Comments 
Hello,

Ther eis not much difference between within and in but within implies more restriction. Errm, to understand better, make a search on the search box right above.
In this case, only 'in' makes sense to me. I wonder what native speakers think.
Students: Are you brave enough to let our tutors analyse your pronunciation?
"In."
florazheng1015Hello! Could someone else explain the difference between 'in' and 'within' about time?

eg1 This is the worst water shortage in 4 years.

eg2 This is the worst water shortage within 4 years.

Thanks in advance!

This is the worst water shortage in 4 years.

There has not been a water shortage as bad as this for four years.

I will finish it within the month = I will finish it before the end of the month.
Within can work in the future tense. I totally agree with you, Optilang. However, in the context provided by the poster, the period spans back in time and I feel only 'in' sounds right. Would you use within? If so, does the meaning still remain the same?
Students: We have free audio pronunciation exercises.
For the sentence posted here I would only use 'in'.
# 1 is the correct usage
# 2 is understood but sounds incorrect.

George Bush has managed to allow oil prices to rise from $25 a barrel when he took office to $148 In less than 8 years.

Within his 2 terms, his approval rating dropped sharply, along with the economy and quality of life.
florazheng1015This is the worst water shortage in 4 years.
during the four-year period ending today
florazheng1015This is the worst water shortage within 4 years.
Anomalous. Here's a better use of "within".

This is the worst water shortage recorded within/in the four-year period from 1992 to 1996.
CJ
Try out our live chat room.
Show more