+0
Hello! Could someone else explain the difference between 'in' and 'within' about time?

eg1 This is the worst water shortage in 4 years.

eg2 This is the worst water shortage within 4 years.

Thanks in advance!
1 2
Comments  
Hello,

Ther eis not much difference between within and in but within implies more restriction. Errm, to understand better, make a search on the search box right above.
In this case, only 'in' makes sense to me. I wonder what native speakers think.
Students: We have free audio pronunciation exercises.
"In."
florazheng1015Hello! Could someone else explain the difference between 'in' and 'within' about time?

eg1 This is the worst water shortage in 4 years.

eg2 This is the worst water shortage within 4 years.

Thanks in advance!

This is the worst water shortage in 4 years.

There has not been a water shortage as bad as this for four years.

I will finish it within the month = I will finish it before the end of the month.
Within can work in the future tense. I totally agree with you, Optilang. However, in the context provided by the poster, the period spans back in time and I feel only 'in' sounds right. Would you use within? If so, does the meaning still remain the same?
Teachers: We supply a list of EFL job vacancies
For the sentence posted here I would only use 'in'.
# 1 is the correct usage
# 2 is understood but sounds incorrect.

George Bush has managed to allow oil prices to rise from $25 a barrel when he took office to $148 In less than 8 years.

Within his 2 terms, his approval rating dropped sharply, along with the economy and quality of life.
florazheng1015This is the worst water shortage in 4 years.
during the four-year period ending today
florazheng1015This is the worst water shortage within 4 years.
Anomalous. Here's a better use of "within".

This is the worst water shortage recorded within/in the four-year period from 1992 to 1996.
CJ
Students: Are you brave enough to let our tutors analyse your pronunciation?
Show more