+0
A: Aren't you going to John's birthday party tonight?

B: What make/made you think so?

A: John is your best friend.
1 2
Comments  
New2grammar
A: Aren't you going to John's birthday party tonight?

B: What make/made you think so?

A: John is your best friend.

"Aren't you going to John's birthday party tonight?" = I think (now, in the present time) that you are going and I want you to confirm this; that is why I am asking you now.

What makes you think so?
Hi guys,

A: Aren't you going to John's birthday party tonight?

B: What make/made you think so?

A: John is your best friend.

If A thinks (now, in the present time) that B is going and A wants B to confirm this, A would more typically say

A: You're going to John's birthday party tonight, aren't you?

Best wishes, Clive

Students: Are you brave enough to let our tutors analyse your pronunciation?
Could you give me an example where 'What made you think so?' is used?

Let me give it a try to see if I get this:

A: I called John yesterday night but you weren't at his party. Weren't you suppose to be there?

B: What made you think so?
Correct
New2grammarA: I called John yesterday night but you weren't at his party. Weren't you suppose to be there?

B: What made you think so?

Just a minor point:

I called John yesterday night but you weren't at his party. Weren't you supposed to be there?
Students: We have free audio pronunciation exercises.
While "makes" is correct, so is "made," IMO, if B means that A has done his thinking some time ago:

A: Aren't you going to John's birthday party tonight?
B: What made you think so?

A: I knew John was/is your best friend.
Marius Hancu, how would B know whether A thought of it earlier and not at the moment of speaking? There is no way for B to read A's mind. Could you please provide an example that would show B has the knowledge on the time A does his thinking?

Thanks in advance.
New2grammarMarius Hancu, how would B know whether A thought of it earlier and not at the moment of speaking?
He would be taking a guess (of course) that the thinking/decision was done earlier (made) or right then and there (makes).
Teachers: We supply a list of EFL job vacancies
Show more