+0
Hi,

This is from a selective cloze exercise, which aims to test semantic precision:

"I was _________ in a village and even though I've now worked in the city for many years ... "

I can choose among four possible answers:
A) reared
B) raised
C) nurtured
D) bred.


I thought both A and B could be correct, which is against the rule of the "game", because only one answer is supposed to be fine.* [:^)]

The only explanation I was able to find here in the forums is this one :

I was taught (egads, 40 years ago) that "you raise animals, you rear children", by a very precise English teacher. However, I have been trying to locate current practice on the use of rear/raise, and it appears that rear has become almost obsolete.
These definitions are from Cambridge online dictionaries :
raise: to take care of a person, or an animal or plant, until they are completely grown
rear: to care for young animals or children until they are able to care for themselves

and these one from Oxford Advanced Learner's dictionary :
raise: (especially NAmE) to care for a child or young animal until it is able to take care of itself:
rear: [often passive] to care for young children or animals until they are fully grown


To sum things up, according to Cambridge dic. there would be no difference between "rear" and "raise" (within this context), while Oxford dic. suggests two reasons for choosing one over the other: active/passive form and BrE/AmE. None of them mentions that one should be used for animals and the other for children.

Sorry for the long introduction ... now I'll ask my question. Emotion: smile
Do you native speakers feel there's any difference between rear and raise? I'm interested in all of the three explanations above given (active/passive, British/American, children/animals).

Thank you!
Emotion: smile

____

*Just for the records, although I don't have the keys yet, I think they expect me to choose "A" ("reared"). However, I'm not merely interested in passing tests; I'd rather know how native speakers use these two words ... If I were to say or write that sentence, I think I'd use "raised" because it seems more natural to me ... but maybe my non-native ear is just failing me!Emotion: sad
1 2 3 4
Comments  
As a choice on a test item, select "reared"; that will very likely be the last time you use it.
Hi,
I wouldn't really distingush between 'raised' and 'reared' here.

I also don't have any problem with 'nurtured'. This simply adds colour to the sentence, by stressing 'raised/reared with kindness, understanding, care'. However, I'm sure that 'nurtured' would not be what the examiner is looking for.

Best wishes, Clive
Site Hint: Check out our list of pronunciation videos.
Thank you both, Clive and Philip!

I have now been given the "correct" answer. Quite surprisingly (well, for me!) they said "raised" is correct and "reared" is wrong. The explanation was, as a child you are reared by somebody but raised in a certain place.

Any thoughts about this one?

(No problem, anyway, that was only a mock test. In real life, I think I'll stick with "raise", as Philip suggested Emotion: smile)
How stupid can tests be? I mean, Clive and Philip would have failed! This is nonsense.
After checking my dictionaries (as you did, Tanit), I came to the conclusion there was basically no difference, at least in that context. My first guess was that "rear" was just much less common, and higher in register (and it looks like I guessed right).
TanitThe explanation was, as a child you are reared by somebody but raised in a certain place.
That seems a sensible explanation if you really take them as idiomatic collocations. The problem is it doesn't really seem to reflect how people use and perceive those words. The New York Times seems full of people reared "somewhere", for example.

http://www.bartleby.com/65/fi/FitzgEl.html - Columbia Encyclopedia
[...] Fitzgerald was reared in Yonkers, N.Y., moving after her mother’s death (1932) to Harlem [...]

http://www.bartleby.com/65/va/VanBuren.html - Columbia Encyclopedia
[...] He was reared on his father’s farm, was educated at local schools [...]

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q="was+reared+in"%3Awww.nytimes.com&btnG=Search
Lots of articles

It really scares me to realize how weird some questions can be, and how weird the answers can be as well. No wonder the average American scores so poorly on tests like the TOEFL. Emotion: rolleyes Sorry if this sounds like a rant, but I think I really hate English tests. [A] Emotion: stick out tongue
Hi,
Kooyeen I came to the conclusion there was basically no difference, at least in that context.
Kooyeen Clive and Philip would have failed! This is nonsense.
You know I completely agree with you, don't you? Emotion: smile
As I trust our natives friends, I posted that explanation to check with them whether it makes sense or not to them.
KooyeenSorry if this sounds like a rant, but I think I really hate English tests
Do you think I love them? Emotion: zip it
The thing is, after completing something else, I thought it was highly time I got back to studying English more seriously than I've done in the recent past and to sit for this certificate (not the TOEFL) I should have taken a couple of years ago. Tests are the only standardized way to assess one's knowledge of the language; unfortunately, though, they are prepared by humans ...

(PS: thanks for the links!)
Students: Are you brave enough to let our tutors analyse your pronunciation?
I am inclined to use "raised" as in a location when talking about people.

An excerpt from http://www.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/nonerrors.html

Crops are raised; children are reared.

Old-fashioned writers insist that you raise crops and rear children; but in modern American English children are usually “raised.”

another quote: from www.dogzonline.co.uk/breeds/breeders/cocker-spaniel.asp
"and parti-colour puppies available having been reared and raised in the home. ... Richian is a small but Quality Show kennel based in Wales in the UK.
..."
just to confuse things, both are used.
I live in Canada and hardly anybody uses reared and not that many people actually understand it. Rear is probably the right answer but I agree you will never use it again. My grandmother says "reared" but she is the only person I have ever heard use it.
Thank you all. Emotion: smile
Teachers: We supply a list of EFL job vacancies
Show more