+0
I've got a question on the use of the verb 'substitute'. For instance, I have the following sentence:
I advised him to take out the word 'crackpot' and substitute the word 'infested'.

What does it mean? Does this sentence mean that I advised someone to take out the word 'crackpot' and substitute the word 'infested' for some other word (abound, for one)? Or does it mean that I advised someone to substitute the word 'crackpot' for 'infested' (it makes no sense, though)?
+0
Although we know that 'crackpot' and 'infested' are not likely able to fill the same grammatical role in a sentence, your sentence as it stands is at best ambiguous. Certainly, if 'crackpot' were wrong, a credulous person could think that 'infested' might replace it:

The student writes: 'His house was crackpot with two-kilogram rats'.

The teacher advises: 'This sentence is wrong; please take out the word 'crackpot' and substitute the word 'infested'.'

Your original sentence should be rewritten to clarify, if you wish 'infested' to subsitute for another word than 'crackpot':

'I advised him to take out the word 'crackpot', and substitute the word 'infested' for the word 'inundated'.
+0
I advised him to take out the word 'crackpot' and substitute the word 'infested'.

What does it mean? Does this sentence mean that ( A ) I advised someone to take out the word 'crackpot' and substitute the word 'infested' for some other word (abound, for one)? Or does it mean that ( B ) I advised someone to substitute the word 'crackpot' for 'infested' (it makes no sense, though)?


It's an odd one, isn't it? On first reading, though, I got ( A ), "substitute the word 'infested' for some other word". The reason I didn't get ( B ): "take out" means to delete, whereas "substitute" means to replace. One cannot replace a word that's been deleted. Moreover, the ( B ) reading is impossible: 'infested' is not a synonym for 'crackpot':

I advised him to replace the word 'crackpot' with the word 'infested'. (??)
Students: Are you brave enough to let our tutors analyse your pronunciation?
Comments  
As far as I know, when you substitute something, you replace something.

.. the word 'crackpot' and replace it with the word 'infested'. doesn't make any sense, so I'd go with your first option:
1. take out the word 'crackpot'
2. subsitute the word 'infested' for another word.
 Mister Micawber's reply was promoted to an answer.
 Casi's reply was promoted to an answer.
Try out our live chat room.
That's just what I was talking about. It seemed quite strange to me, so I decided to find out which variant was correct. I saw a similar structure somewhere on the web and the author of that sentence probably made a mistake because he meant (B). The author was a native speakerEmotion: indifferent
Ah, yes, and we are human before we are native speakers.