Which Construction Does This Conditional Sentence Conform?

ForumsGrammar & Sentence Structure
  •  2
+0
Should she smoak my design upon Cynthia , I were in a fine pickle.
Which construction does this conditional sentence conform? I mean Why it is not I'd be in a fine pickle or ... .
Thanks for your answers
+0
coloradayShould she smoak my design upon Cynthia , I were in a fine pickle.
Which construction does this conditional sentence conform to?
This is obviously not modern English. It was written long ago, in a time when the grammar of English allowed such structures.

Archaic structure: Should he ask Lucy that question, she were quite embarrassed.
Modern equivalent: If he asked Lucy that question, she would be quite embarrassed.

CJ
+0
CJ is quite right. Cf.

1. If it were done when 'tis done, then 'twere well / It were done quickly (Macbeth)

The construction is:

2. If X were the case, Y were the case.

The form with the subjunctive in the main clause (the "apodosis") preceded the construction with "would":

3. If X were the case, Y would be the case.

It began to disappear from English texts in the 19th century; you will often encounter it in the plays of Congreve, Wycherley, etc., but seldom in modern texts.

MrP
Teachers: We supply a list of EFL job vacancies
1 2
Comments  
This sentence is written by someone who is not fluent in English, so it is pointless to analyze it.
There is no such verb as smoak.
This sentence is from The Double Dealer by William Congreve , a great english comedy writer in 18 th century. And for the meaning of Smoak I'd refer you to this page .
Thanks
Coloraday:
Sorry, but if you had indicated the source in your first post, I would have looked in my OED and given a different answer. "Smoak" is not listed in the on-line dictionaries. The style might also be regional, as well as old.
Site Hint: Check out our list of pronunciation videos.
 CalifJim's reply was promoted to an answer.
AlpheccaStarsColoraday:

Sorry, but if you had indicated the source in your first post, I would have looked in my OED and given a different answer. "Smoak" is not listed in the on-line dictionaries.  The style might also be regional, as well as old.

Sorry , I should have indicated the source. 

CalifJimArchaic structure:  Should he ask Lucy that question, she were quite embarrassed.
Modern equivalent:  If he asked Lucy that question, she would be quite embarrassed.
Where is your source for these sentences?
CalifJimWhich construction does this conditional sentence conform to?
Thank you for the correction .
Students: Are you brave enough to let our tutors analyse your pronunciation?
coloradayWhere is your source for these sentences?
In my head. I made up an example to show the contrast between archaic grammar and modern grammar. What did you expect? Shakespeare? Emotion: smile

CJ
I think your head is not a dependable reference for archaic grammar.
thank you
Show more

Answer this Question

Guides