+0
Hi!

please can someone tell me why I use "me" and not "I" in this sentence:

"why me?" and not "Why I?"

Thanks

Pamela
+1
Pamela81... can someone tell me why I use "me" and not "I" in ...
"why me?"
I don't think anyone can tell you why. Emotion: smile

We just say it like that: Why me?

But in a complete sentence, we use I. Why should I be the one who does it?

It's strange, but true. Emotion: smile

CJ
Comments  
Students: We have free audio pronunciation exercises.
Pamela81"why me?" and not "Why I?"
When some shouts out this expression, an unexpected event or something he didn't not wish for has happened in his life. So if you say "Why me!", you express perhaps a mixed feeling of "why didn't this happen to somebody else, but me"( Me- as in the objective case, as a recipient of the misfortune and punishment ).
Hi CJ!

Thanks for the reply.

You mean that there´s no grammatical rule behind it?

But if I say: "that´s me who can solve the situation" isn´t any rule as well for the choice of me instead of I?

Thanks for your feedback

Pamela
I think it's "why me" because the word "me" (although it is a noun) indicates in this context an object.

Let's take a look at this example:

"He chose me to put on his show. Why me?" In other words, why am I the one he decided to choose?

You say "why me" because you show an unpleasant act he did towards you.

The question "why me" has a complaint tone, and therefore it is obvious you speak about something happened towards you. You are not the one who did the action; you are the one whom the action has been directed to.

Good luck!
Teachers: We supply a list of EFL job vacancies
Pamela81You mean that there´s no grammatical rule behind it?
Well, I suppose I could say that the grammatical rule is to use the object pronoun after "why". That IS the rule. Emotion: smile

Why me? Why her? Why him? Why us? Why them? Why you?

A more general rule is to use I (we, he, she, they) for the subject of a sentence, and use me (us, him, her, them) in all other situations.

Pamela81But if I say: "that´s me who can solve the situation"
That's me who ... isn't good English. Say I'm the one who ...

CJ

"why me?" is re-phrase of a truncated sentence which usually involves an action verb: why pick me?; why did you do that to me?; why did you give me so much money?; ... I suppose "why I" could be used to truncate a non-action verb phrase, but off-hand I can't think of one that would not be silly: You are silly. - Why I (why am I silly)?.