+0
Hi guys,

I've been thinking about this for quite some time. Many people from US companys often aswer me in the present perfect like:

Thank you, I've received your e-mail OR Yves, I've spoken to my boss and he...or Yves, I've forwarded your mail to our finance department and it will be processed soon!

Am I wrong or would you use simple past at least in spoken english? Like: Thank you, I got you mail(I received your mail) or Yves, I spoke to my boss and he said...

What's your opinion on this?
1 2 3
Comments  
YSchneiderThank you, I've received your e-mail OR Yves, I've spoken to my boss and he...or Yves, I've forwarded your mail to our finance department and it will be processed soon!
Hi YSchneider

It sounds like someone might have told you that Americans hardly ever use the present perfect, and that you are now noticing that that just isn't true. Am I right?

Anyway, to answer your question, yes, it is also possible to use the simple past tense in the sentences you posted. Personally, though, I think I'd prefer the present perfect.

By the way, is you name Yves?
Yes, my name is Yves. Emotion: smile and Yes you're right I thought that Americans they won't use present perfect that much!

You said that you'd also prefer the present perect? Could explain me why? Because for me there is now reason to assume I should use the present perfect. I mean let's think about it. I've spoken to my boss..

it certainly happened in the past and probably even some time ago(not right before) also I cannot feel that the present is affected like: The weather has changed! = the weather is diffrent now

(I feel also the same about I've received and so on)

Can you try to explain this to me? Thanks!!!
Students: Are you brave enough to let our tutors analyse your pronunciation?
If it is the present perfect used after an action, ("I have eaten" for example), the reason it is used is because the action has caused a state that is still current (present).
A: Do you fancy going out for lunch? B: No thanks. I'm not hungry. I have already eaten.
Hi Yankee, would you mind to have a look at my post? I'd like to hear your opinion on this!Emotion: smile
Hi Huevos

That probably wasn't the best example to give because, in the US, you're just as likely to hear "No, thanks. I already ate." Emotion: stick out tongue
Site Hint: Check out our list of pronunciation videos.
So Yankee what would make you choose the present perfect in the mentioned sentences? What's your feeling on that?
Yankee"No, thanks. I already ate."
I´ve always been taught using "already" with simple past is a grammatical error.
Hi Yves

I'd say there are a couple of reasons for my (personal) preference of the present perfect in the examples you gave earlier:

1. The past activities I'm mentioning in the email probably took place extremely recently, and the fact that I'm currently writing about those very recent events provides an extremely direct and clear connection to the present and me.
2. Precisely when I spoke to my boss or precisely when I forwarded you mail is not important. It is only important THAT those things were done.

As I said in my last post, however, I can also imagine an American using the simple past tense.

To give you a different sort of example, imagine that someone shot the US president. I cannot imagine any American running around and giving people the news by saying "The president has been shot!" Instead, I would expect the simple past tense: "Hey! Did you hear? Some yahoo shot the president!"
Teachers: We supply a list of EFL job vacancies
Show more